ARUNDEL, Maine — Blood tests performed on Arundel dairy farmer Fred Stone, who became the face of PFAS contamination in Maine when his farm was shutdown due to its impact, show levels of the “forever chemicals” 20 times the national average more than two years after he and his wife stopped drinking the milk and water on the farm.
On June 11, 2019, blood samples were drawn by the Stone family’s physician and sent to a laboratory in California. Test results show Stone’s blood contains PFAS levels of 111 parts per billion, and his wife, Laura Stone, tested for PFAS levels of 93.5 ppb.
According to the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, a program conducted by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average American has a level of approximately 4.7 ppb in their blood.
Studies have found exposure to elevated PFAS levels may cause serious health problems, including cancer, damage to the liver and immune systems, developmental effects to fetuses during pregnancy or to breastfed infants, thyroid conditions and high cholesterol.
Stone was licensed in the 1980s to spread wastewater sludge on his fields and others across York County, but he said he never knew they contained PFAS chemicals.
“When the contamination was discovered at the farm, we assumed that it must have gotten inside of our bodies because we have been drinking the water and milk for many years,” Fred Stone said. “These blood test results add injury to insult. First, it was our farm, then it was our cows and now it’s us? When will this nightmare end?”
Attorney Benjamin Gideon of Berman & Simmons and his partner, attorney Susan Faunce, represent the Stones and Stoneridge Farm. Gideon said his clients “face a lifetime of negative health consequences.” The Stones have filed a lawsuit against the manufacturers of the PFAS substances, including 3M and Dupont, and those responsible for spreading the contaminated sludge on their farm.
Gideon said the suit was filed in York County Superior Court, and a judge granted an extension when Gideon took over the case from the Stone’s previous legal counsel. Defendants will include municipal sewer districts in Kennebunk and Ogunquit as Stone was licensed to spread their sludge, and the paper company S.D. Warren in Westbrook, now owned by Sappi, along with the big chemical companies and their spinoff companies, Gideon said. He has until November to serve the complaint to those named, he said.
“We expected that the Stones would have elevated PFAS levels in their blood, but these numbers are shocking, particularly given that they stopped drinking the contaminated water and milk almost two years ago,” Gideon said.
PFAS contamination at Stoneridge Farm was identified after the chemicals were detected in the water at the Kennebunk, Kennebunkport, Wells Water District’s Kimball Lane well in West Kennebunk, which was shut down in 2017.
Further testing at the Stone property revealed high levels of one type of PFAS compound, perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS), in the drinking water, soil, hay and cow milk. PFAS are a class of synthetic chemicals that never biodegrade in the environment, earning them the label of “forever chemicals.” As a result of the contamination, the Stones have been forced to discontinue selling their milk and have had to shut down operations at their farm. The loss of business has been emotionally and financially devastating, Gideon said.
Norm Labbe, former KKWWD superintendent, previously said the Kimball Lane well has been back online since June 8, 2018, with a full-scale carbon filtration system that has kept PFAS to an undetectable level. Labbe said the well produces an average of 1 million gallons a day for the district. The carbon for the filtration system costs the district $30,000 to $40,000 a year, he said.
Stone was able to get the PFAS in his herd’s milk down to zero by purchasing a new herd from New York that had not been exposed to the farm’s water and feed, installing a $20,000 water filtration system and purchasing feed from out-of-state sources where hay is grown in fields not spread with sludge.
“Financially, we’re sinking,” he said. “Besides the filtration system and the feed, our costs include every bill for investigating and testing the water and monitoring the milk, and the loss to the value of our real estate. This whole thing has been a nightmare.”
Gov. Janet Mills in March announced the creation of a governor’s task force to mobilize state agencies and other stakeholders to review the prevalence of PFAS in Maine and to put forward a plan to address the chemicals.
The potential widespread impact of PFAS in Maine is a concern, Gideon said.
“We are also concerned that the Stones are not alone,” he said. “Most locations in Maine where municipal and paper company sludge were spread have not yet been tested for PFAS. We do not know how many farms or private wells are contaminated or how many Maine people face serious health risks from exposure to these dangerous ‘forever’ chemicals. Through our lawsuit, we plan to try to find answers to these important questions.
“Our main focus is that whatever caused these problems, it’s not isolated to this one place, it’s likely to have caused problems in other places. We want to work out in concentric circles to investigate all of the logical inferences.”
Gideon added people shouldn’t panic, particularly if they don’t live near a landfill or on an aquifer near a farm where sludge was dumped.
“We talk to people a lot who have concerns and we want to hear from them,” he said. “Most of the time we can put their minds at ease. But we want to identify other places where this contamination might exist.
Maine residents with concerns about potential PFAS contamination on their property should call Gideon or attorney Susan Faunce at Berman & Simmons at (207) 784-3576.
Watch: Aging Monroe dairy farmer faces struggles in trying to retire