Once a host to presidents, historic Bucksport inn up for auction

The current owner of the former Jed Prouty Inn, located on
Main Street in Bucksport, will attempt to sell the historic building
during an online auction from Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2011, to Thursday,
Oct. 13, 2011. Built around 1780, the 17-bedroom inn has hosted
presidents and other famous figures. But it has sat vacant for nearly
eight years and is in need of significant renovations and repairs.
The current owner of the former Jed Prouty Inn, located on Main Street in Bucksport, will attempt to sell the historic building during an online auction from Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2011, to Thursday, Oct. 13, 2011. Built around 1780, the 17-bedroom inn has hosted presidents and other famous figures. But it has sat vacant for nearly eight years and is in need of significant renovations and repairs.
Posted Oct. 10, 2011, at 7:33 p.m.
Last modified Oct. 10, 2011, at 8:06 p.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     

BUCKSPORT, Maine — A 230-year-old Bucksport landmark that has hosted presidents, arctic explorers and other famous figures but has sat lifeless for the better part of a decade is about to go on the auction block.

The Jed Prouty Inn, as the building is still known, is a 17-bedroom former hotel that has anchored Bucksport’s Main Street in one form or another since about 1780. Now the financial firm that acquired the building after the last business closed nearly eight years ago is hoping a buyer will emerge during an online auction held Tuesday through Thursday.

Bidding will start at $30,000 for the property. But no matter how much the Jed Prouty sells for — if it sells at all, that is — any potential buyer should be prepared to pay out significant sums to get the old inn back to usable shape.

“We’re hoping someone will come along and buy the building and give her the tender loving care that she needs,” said Janet Baron-Murphy, a Camden-based real estate agent who estimates she has shown the building 125 times to potential buyers in recent years. “She is a mainstay of the community.”

Originally built as a two-family home, the building was converted to an inn sometime around 1820.

Over the years, the inn’s clients included several presidents — Martin Van Buren, James Buchanan, John Tyler, William Henry Harrison — as well as statesman Daniel Webster. Admiral Robert Peary, who is credited with leading the first expedition to the North Pole, reportedly stayed at the inn for months while his expedition’s ship was under construction in Bucksport.

But the building has sat vacant for much of the past quarter-century. Town officials have watched with growing concern as the building continued to deteriorate after an assisted living business moved out in March 2004. The building is now owned by an affiliate of the Lehman Bros. financial firm.

The building underwent extensive renovations in the late 1990s to install sprinkler systems, an elevator and other features to bring the structure up to code for the assisted living facility. The building also has a full commercial kitchen — complete with equipment — as well as a tavern.

However, a recent architectural survey commissioned by the town estimated it would cost more than $250,000 to repair the former inn. For instance, the large front porch on the three-story building will have to be replaced, as will a retaining wall at the rear of the building.

“It would be a shame to see it rot away any more than it has,” said David Keene, Bucksport mayor and Town Council chairman.

Baron-Murphy, who works for Prudential Northeast Properties, said she fielded a few calls on the property on Monday. Past offers have ranged from $75,000 to $550,000, but none of those deals was ever completed. The most recent asking price was just under $300,000.

One couple that will be watching the auction closely is John and Rhonda Chambers.

The Chambers, who live in Calais, already operate five senior housing facilities in Maine and have been in discussions with Bucksport officials about expanding to the town, possibly to the Jed Prouty building.

The Bucksport Town Council held a public hearing in late September to gauge residents’ feelings about whether the town should offer the Chambers $150,000 to $200,000 in financial assistance to renovate the Jed Prouty.

Keene said Monday that the town’s money would have to be used for specific, pre-approved improvements to bring the building up to code. Keene said the assistance likely would be a type of loan that gradually would be forgiven as long as the assisted living facility remained in business.

But before town officials would offer the Chambers or any other buyer money to save the Jed Prouty, they would have to be convinced that the new owners have a viable business plan, he said.

Keene said there appears to be a lot of support among residents for using town money to help pay for renovations in order to save the historic building. “But then again, we are looking for some sort of business plan … to prove it is going to be a viable business before the town commits any money,” he said.

John Chambers said Monday that the couple does not plan to participate in the online auction but will monitor it before deciding whether to put in their own offer on the building. But even if the Jed Prouty building is sold to someone else, Chambers said he and his wife still are interested in establishing an assisted living facility in Bucksport to meet the needs of the area.

“We are still going to work with the town to find an alternative,” Chambers said.

For information about the auction, visit http://bdn.to/proutyauction.

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BE5K4BY6CK2TFMMTWIM5B22ZOE David

    Lots of good times in the bar on Friday/Saturday nights in the early 80s. That place was rockin’ back then.

    Food was great in the dining room, too, as well as breakfast in the front room.

  • Anonymous

    Bringing back an inn would be great! Good food, drink, and company–would be an asset to the town.

  • http://twitter.com/tamarak333 Tamara Kepner

    It would be good to see new life come to this building.

  • Anonymous

    Tear ‘er down….

  • Anonymous

    My father’s favorite bar in his drinking days, my grandparents entertained their friends there, I went to breakfast and had pancakes with my grandfather it was my special time alone with him as a child. Learned my manners when I went to dinner at the Jed Prouty with them. Attended weddings there when I lived in Bucksport. It was a thing of beauty. Senior Citizen apartments, oh well that is what happened to the Catholic School on the hill, lots and lots of apartments.

  • Anonymous

    I hope it opens as an inn again! Dad used to take us there sometimes—on special Sundays usually.

  • Anonymous

    It would be so nice to see it saved and properly restored…it’s such a beautiful old building with a significant history. There aren’t too many 230-year-old houses left anywhere these days, and this one is worth maintaining (and not as a senior home–that didn’t work last time). The problem: who’s going to spend that kind of cash?

  • Pamela Charette

    I also had some good times at Jed Prouty Inn in the eighties….the place had character..I no longer live in the area…my ex hubby and I would take a fall motorcycle ride and stop at the tavern for a hot apple cider drink and then head home.  Great place I hope someone takes it over and gives it the love it needs.

  • Anonymous

    Hope someone with integrity buys the place before the town tears it down, which is what they are now proposing if it doesn’t get sold.

  • Anonymous

    Want to know what the problem is?  Look at the property tax bill on this place!  The town drove this property into the ground by assessing an unsustainably high property tax.  But hey, the town has a recreation department, lake front property, new schools, senior center, and a river walk.  Geez all sorts of good stuff.

  • Anonymous

    Actually, the problem with this place is that its in Bucksport.  Nobody wants to stay in a hotel with a factory view.

  • Anonymous

    Bucksport’s mil rate is 12.48 watchdog. What’s yours? Better to keep your mouth closed and thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt. 

  • Anonymous

    Where the heck is Bucksnort?

  • Anonymous

    Hey , what about that beautiful view of a freakin’ TANK FARM in front of that beautiful hotel called Hollywood in beautiful Bangor!? 
     BTW the so called “factory” is not in view of the JP H.  Actually the bridge and Ft. Knox are the view you would get from Jed Prouty Hotel.Know what you’re talking about.  

  • Anonymous

    It doesn’t matter what the mil rate is if a property is assessed high.  You know that too don’t you, jerk!  I know all about Bucksport, I used to live there.  The property tax on my home freaking doubled in about 6 years.  I moved out.  Meanwhile the town continues to spend as though there is no limit to the money residents can/will put up for taxes.  Better hope the mill doesn’t close.  You guys will be, well, you know the word.

  • Anonymous

    Watchdog, since Maine law dictates how properties are valued and the state regularly reviews those assessments to make sure that they are in line with fair market values, how can a community get away with assessing them too high?  I thought that if I felt my property was assessed too high, that I could appeal that decision to the State board of appeals and if my values are in fact too high, I would prevail? Is that not the case? 

    And you are right, the mill is very valuable to the people in Bucksport. But even after reducing their property taxes by over $500,000 a year (yes, by reducing spending and lowering the mil rate. I understand that is a surprise to you) over the past five years, they still have to make tough business decisions like they have done today. And I also understand that folks like yourself will smile and revel at the loss of 125 workers in Bucksport. You should be so proud!        

  • Anonymous

    Yup, the mill just closed a machine.  Better start figuring another way to raise revenue.  As for fair market values, that’s a load of dung and you know it!  Town property assessments lag fair market value by years.  I know first hand of many, who like myself, have left Bucksport because of the “fair market value” being ridiculously high.  Property tax appeals??? That’s a laugh.  Come on, lets be serious here.  Look, I understand that Bucksport is like any other town in America.  They want the town to be the best it can be.  I have no gripe with that.  But Bucksport is notorious for spending taxpayer money, and the town spends it on things which are not essential, ridiculously non-essential.  Hmm, I wonder why the old bank downtown has been on the market for so long?   Almost as long as the Inn.  Could it be the taxes?  What are the taxes on the Inn now?  I no longer live in the immediate area but you seem to be up on these things.  What $20,000, $30,000, $50,000/year maybe?  Gee I wonder if the high taxes have anything to do with so many failed businesses in downtown.  Oh, now you’re going to say that the business failure rate is no worse in Bucksport than any other town around the area.  Perhaps you’re right.  Maybe they have the same problem with controlling their spending.

  • Anonymous

    Tear ‘er down….

  • Anonymous

    I remember the 80′s at JP.  I played in a band that rocked the bar in those days.  Great place to play. Fantastic Prime Rib and had quite a bit of “fun” in the rooms after the bar had closed for the night.

  • Anonymous

    I looked on the town’s website and it shows the taxes on that building are about $6,000 a year and it is a 14,000 sq ft building. That seems like a lot compared to my 3 bed room residence at $3,000 a year. But certainly less than your predictions. The Old Bank is listed for sale at $399,000 (It has recently been lowered from $499,000). Should there be many takers at that price? Do you really think that the $342,000 assessment that the town has on it (same website) is inflated? Could it POSSIBLY be that the reason properties (including the Jed Prouty) are not moving is because the owners think they have some kind of a gold mine?

    I don’t mind discussing issues civilly but when I see how fiscally conservative the Bucksport Town Council has been with citizens money and then  read comments like yours  that are obviously based on no known factual information, ya, it gets under my skin.  And before you ask, No, I’m not on the Town Council. But I do know every one of the councilors and respect the work they are doing. Lastly, remember that Bucksport is very similar to most communities in Maine in that about 75% of the budget goes to education.  

  • Anonymous

    I also prefer to be civil however that went out the window when you said, “Better to keep your mouth closed and thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt.”

    I may have been off a bit on my low ball guess at the tax on the Inn but not too far. As for the rest, I stand by my opinions.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_G6B34TO6VSGMWPGBXMXNQGP7AI Dana

    So the inn has been vacant for eight years. Is there any particular reason for that? I will ask the question. Any reported hauntings?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BE5K4BY6CK2TFMMTWIM5B22ZOE David

    What was the name of your band? There was one that was, well, not the house band, but played there very often, and they were great. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BE5K4BY6CK2TFMMTWIM5B22ZOE David

    You have no idea what you’re talking about.

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business