Islesboro voters approve killing 400 deer to help prevent Lyme disease

Posted Aug. 25, 2011, at 2:30 p.m.
Last modified Aug. 25, 2011, at 4:03 p.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     

ISLESBORO, Maine — The deer are doomed. Voters here decided Wednesday night to kill about 400 of the about 500 deer on the island. There are almost as many deer on the island as there are year-round residents and the voters blame the animals for a Lyme disease “epidemic” in the small community.

The island does not yet know how it will maintain a low deer population once most of the herd has been harvested. To figure out the best option for the 11-mile long island, the board of selectmen will form a wildlife management group.

The vote was 100 to 28 to reduce the deer herd. The island will cull the herd from about 50 deer per square mile to 10 deer per square mile — and then work to maintain that population.

The deer on the island are the only breeding and feeding ground for ticks. Half of the ticks on the island carry Lyme bacteria, which can cause Lyme disease in tick-bit humans.

On the island of 600 year-round residents, about 70 of them have contracted the disease. At least 20 were diagnosed this year, plus at least 20 more suspected cases that were unconfirmed, but treated. That, for a small community, makes it a Lyme disease epidemic, according to Islesboro’s Tick-Borne Disease Prevention Committee.

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • Anonymous

    We need to do the same thing on MDI. My two year old son just got biten by a tick and got the red bulls eye rash and is being treated for lyme! I am pis$ed! I never seen this before in my life and now my little boy has it! This is not acceptable.

  • Anonymous

    We need to do the same thing on MDI. My two year old son just got biten by a tick and got the red bulls eye rash and is being treated for lyme! I am pis$ed! I never seen this before in my life and now my little boy has it! This is not acceptable.

  • Anonymous

    We need to do the same thing on MDI. My two year old son just got biten by a tick and got the red bulls eye rash and is being treated for lyme! I am pis$ed! I never seen this before in my life and now my little boy has it! This is not acceptable.

  • Anonymous

    We need to do the same thing on MDI. My two year old son just got biten by a tick and got the red bulls eye rash and is being treated for lyme! I am pis$ed! I never seen this before in my life and now my little boy has it! This is not acceptable.

  • Anonymous

    We need to do the same thing on MDI. My two year old son just got biten by a tick and got the red bulls eye rash and is being treated for lyme! I am pis$ed! I never seen this before in my life and now my little boy has it! This is not acceptable.

  • Anonymous

    We need to do the same thing on MDI. My two year old son just got biten by a tick and got the red bulls eye rash and is being treated for lyme! I am pis$ed! I never seen this before in my life and now my little boy has it! This is not acceptable.

  • Anonymous

    Why don’t they tranquilize the deer and haul them up to northern Maine? The past few winters have kiiled off the herd. No doe permits are issued up there.  That would be the sensible thing to do, but not cost effective.

  • Anonymous

    Only problem is that’d probably spread the disease up there where it isn’t yet… probably because the deer numbers are so low.

  • Anonymous

    Only problem is that’d probably spread the disease up there where it isn’t yet… probably because the deer numbers are so low.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe a little deer predation would be a good thing to protect people.

  • Anonymous

    would fill quite a few freezers and feed a lot of hungry people. i’d hate to hear that they went to waste.

  • Anonymous

    would fill quite a few freezers and feed a lot of hungry people. i’d hate to hear that they went to waste.

  • Anonymous

    would fill quite a few freezers and feed a lot of hungry people. i’d hate to hear that they went to waste.

  • Benevolent Despot

    They need to rid the island of all the deer and hire guinea hens to clean the ticks up, among other methods.

  • Benevolent Despot

    They need to rid the island of all the deer and hire guinea hens to clean the ticks up, among other methods.

  • Anonymous

    So how about allowing hunting? 

  • Anonymous

    So how about allowing hunting? 

  • Anonymous

    So how about allowing hunting? 

  • Anonymous

    So how about allowing hunting? 

  • Anonymous

    So how about allowing hunting? 

  • Anonymous

    So how about allowing hunting? 

  • Benevolent Despot

    Because they don’t belong up here especially with their ticks.
    It is sort of like illegally dumping bass into a trout pond…

  • Benevolent Despot

    Because they don’t belong up here especially with their ticks.
    It is sort of like illegally dumping bass into a trout pond…

  • Benevolent Despot

    Because they don’t belong up here especially with their ticks.
    It is sort of like illegally dumping bass into a trout pond…

  • Nicky Nickolan

    How did the ticks with lyme disease get there in the first place? Did the deers take the ferry over and party on the mainland then head back to the Island? Maybe instead of blaming deers you could just get a bunch of chickens to eat the ticks. Do you people seriously think birds dont fly by and drop ticks. Then you humans will be the only breeding and feeding on the island – can we hunt you down and kill you too? Why do Mainers alays think kiliing is the answer to every animal issue??

  • Anonymous

    I know that there is a health issue…but,  isn’t there another way?
    May we never get to the point that we start ‘treating’ highly contagious or lethal human diseases with the same swift solution. Oh, wait….euthanasia, I forgot.

  • Anonymous

    yeah bring in a pack of wolves

  • Anonymous

    Wow, please tell me that you don’t have kids?

    Birds don’t “drop” ticks, and if the ticks are using the deer to complete their life cycle then it is a perfectly logical method of cutting the tick population?

    CHICKENS? REALLY? Do you drive a prius?

  • Anonymous

    Wow, please tell me that you don’t have kids?

    Birds don’t “drop” ticks, and if the ticks are using the deer to complete their life cycle then it is a perfectly logical method of cutting the tick population?

    CHICKENS? REALLY? Do you drive a prius?

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • Anonymous

    I hope they process the meat and give it to homeless shelters and soup kitchens around the state and not just let it rot.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4CKS3PK5BXBTBCTZ4YP3UPYVKA Jack – Lu

    Let’s all hope the residents go ‘gun crazy’ all the while they’re culling the herd.  Sounds like a small island with only so much room to hunt. Would be really sad if someone was hit by a stray bullet–worse, if  it  hit someone who has lyme disease!

  • Anonymous

    Deer are not as resilient as some other species and typically do not survive being relocated.

  • Anonymous

    Look for a whole raft of venison recipes from Sandy Oliver.  Since they’ve got 5 times the number of deer per square mile as the mainland, there can’t be a vegetable garden that’ll survive on the island.

  • Anonymous

    It’s a thought process like that, which gives hunters a bad image.  On these small communities it could be very successful using archery.  Firearms should not be used in rural areas except by professionals and only then if it is safe and legal to do so.  You don’t need a whole ton of room for archery to be an effective management tool, in fact it happens all over the country in much more populated places.

  • Anonymous

    It’s a thought process like that, which gives hunters a bad image.  On these small communities it could be very successful using archery.  Firearms should not be used in rural areas except by professionals and only then if it is safe and legal to do so.  You don’t need a whole ton of room for archery to be an effective management tool, in fact it happens all over the country in much more populated places.

  • Anonymous

    Deer can swim quite far, how do you think they got there in the first place.  Ticks may carry disease, and deer carry ticks, deer can swim, and that’s how it all got there.  Chickens wouldn’t curb the tick population enough to limit the spread of lyme disease on that island, for something like that to work the foliage can’t be thick anywhere, and low enough to the ground with so many chickens that it’s just not even remotely feasible.  Not all Mainers think killing is the only option, if it were so simple as one or two problem deer, relocation could be looked at but it’s not.  It is a high density of deer that is the issue and maintaining a smaller density of deer there will be the most effective way to limit lyme disease on the island.

  • Anonymous

    Deer can swim quite far, how do you think they got there in the first place.  Ticks may carry disease, and deer carry ticks, deer can swim, and that’s how it all got there.  Chickens wouldn’t curb the tick population enough to limit the spread of lyme disease on that island, for something like that to work the foliage can’t be thick anywhere, and low enough to the ground with so many chickens that it’s just not even remotely feasible.  Not all Mainers think killing is the only option, if it were so simple as one or two problem deer, relocation could be looked at but it’s not.  It is a high density of deer that is the issue and maintaining a smaller density of deer there will be the most effective way to limit lyme disease on the island.

  • Anonymous

    Deer can swim quite far, how do you think they got there in the first place.  Ticks may carry disease, and deer carry ticks, deer can swim, and that’s how it all got there.  Chickens wouldn’t curb the tick population enough to limit the spread of lyme disease on that island, for something like that to work the foliage can’t be thick anywhere, and low enough to the ground with so many chickens that it’s just not even remotely feasible.  Not all Mainers think killing is the only option, if it were so simple as one or two problem deer, relocation could be looked at but it’s not.  It is a high density of deer that is the issue and maintaining a smaller density of deer there will be the most effective way to limit lyme disease on the island.

  • Anonymous

    they got infected by liberal democrats

  • Anonymous

    they got infected by liberal democrats

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    the meat is still good we can save some money at our prisions

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Anonymous

    live trap 500 coyotes transplant them there

  • Cuddles O’donovan

    cattle drive em to the state house and have a bbq; for the DHHS retirement party !

  • Anonymous

    Like the thought but who pays for it

  • Anonymous

    Like the thought but who pays for it

  • Anonymous

    Like the thought but who pays for it

  • Anonymous

    Like the thought but who pays for it

  • Anonymous

    Like the thought but who pays for it

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • Anonymous

    I am sure there are plenty of more than willing hunters who would relish the opportunity for free

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Isabelle-Wallace-Warren/1674549096 Isabelle Wallace Warren

    Wonder why insecticide to kill the ticks hasn’t been mentioned ? Makes a lot more sense to me than killing deer since mice and other critters carry the ticks too.

  • lwilley

    Um, wouldn’t that just be bringing Lyme’s Disease to northern Maine?

  • nicker7

    I think this is a great idea…..the State wastes alot of money on so many things, at least this is for disease control.

  • Anonymous

    I think that would be adding insult to injury.  Coyotes don’t eat just deer and they breed just as fast. Firsst thingg you know, the island would be overrun with coyotes.

  • Anonymous

    Coyotes eat moose, deer, mice, ants, plants, humans, cats, ground hogs, birds and especially rabbits.  An added bonus..the rabies would keep the human invasive species in check.

  • Anonymous

    This is very informative: 

    http://www.ct.gov/caes/lib/caes/documents/special_features/tickhandbook.pdf

    It shows many and varied methods to alleviate the problem.

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business