Senate president calls for apology for ‘scurrilous’ accusations

Posted Aug. 23, 2011, at 8:14 p.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     
Senate President Kevin Raye, R-Perry, listens to debate on the budget in the Senate at the State House in Augusta, Maine, on Thursday, June 16, 2011.
AP Photo/Pat Wellenbach
Senate President Kevin Raye, R-Perry, listens to debate on the budget in the Senate at the State House in Augusta, Maine, on Thursday, June 16, 2011.

AUGUSTA, Maine — An offhand comment at Tuesday’s public hearing on congressional redistricting has stirred up a controversy that underscores a broad and deepening partisan battle in Maine’s capitol.

Susan Cook of Bath, who spoke in favor of the Democrats’ plan for redrawing the state’s two congressional districts, used part of her time to levy allegations against Maine Senate President Kevin Raye.

Cook claimed that Raye, a Republican from Perry, has been secretly recording phone calls from constituents without their permission, and she wanted the public to be aware of his conduct.

The woman, who happens to be the secretary for the Maine Democratic Party, left Tuesday’s hearing before she could expand on or clarify those comments. Party Spokeswoman Lizzy Reinholt said Cook was not planning to speak to the press.

Raye, who did not attend Tuesday’s hearing in Augusta, heard about Cook’s statement later and called the accusations “very serious,” “baseless” and “scurrilous.”

“I have never taped a phone call in my life,” he said by phone later in the day. “I’m not sure I would know how.”

Cook provided no evidence for her claims. Either way, Maine is one of many states that follow one-party consent laws for telephone recording. That means no permission is needed for one person to tape-record a conversation.

Raye, however, said the law matters less than his name being attached to such behavior.

“I think she should apologize to me and to the people of Maine, who I believe she misrepresented,” the Senate president said.

Maine GOP Chairman Charlie Webster went one step further. He called for Cook’s resignation.

“This is just the latest in a series of recent attacks by Maine Democrats to divert attention from Republican successes,” Webster said. “Democrats have failed in their assault on Republican job-creating policies championed by the Senate President so they have resorted to personal attacks.”

Ben Grant, chairman of the Maine Democratic Party, stressed Tuesday afternoon that Cook was speaking as an individual and not on behalf of the party.

“To be perfectly honest, we were completely caught off guard by the comments made by Susan today,” Grant said. “Regardless of who she was speaking on behalf of, our party values facts and honesty, which is why we are looking into her accusations and we will deal with this accordingly.”

Although Cook did not make the link, Raye’s name likely was mentioned Tuesday during the redistricting discussion because his name has been mentioned as a possible challenger to 2nd District U.S. Rep. Mike Michaud.

Many Democrats believe the GOP’s redistricting plan is an attempt to make the 2nd District more competitive for Republicans.

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • Anonymous

    Typical Democrat, make a baseless accusation with no facts to support the claim. President Raye, please hold her accountable.  Ms Cook, please bring on the evidence or resign.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Don’t you even dare. We’re taking this just as seriously as the GOP is. Unless you want to show me the article with the comments that you made demanding Charlie Webster’s resignation for his similarly “baseless” accusations of us carting bloody Job Corps students around the state, I’d advise you shut your fool mouth.

    Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. If these accusations are false I will be right there calling for her resignation. Somehow, however, I think I’ll wait until Satan is giving free sleigh rides before GOP leadership does the same.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Don’t you even dare. We’re taking this just as seriously as the GOP is. Unless you want to show me the article with the comments that you made demanding Charlie Webster’s resignation for his similarly “baseless” accusations of us carting bloody Job Corps students around the state, I’d advise you shut your fool mouth.

    Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. If these accusations are false I will be right there calling for her resignation. Somehow, however, I think I’ll wait until Satan is giving free sleigh rides before GOP leadership does the same.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Don’t you even dare. We’re taking this just as seriously as the GOP is. Unless you want to show me the article with the comments that you made demanding Charlie Webster’s resignation for his similarly “baseless” accusations of us carting bloody Job Corps students around the state, I’d advise you shut your fool mouth.

    Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. If these accusations are false I will be right there calling for her resignation. Somehow, however, I think I’ll wait until Satan is giving free sleigh rides before GOP leadership does the same.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Don’t you even dare. We’re taking this just as seriously as the GOP is. Unless you want to show me the article with the comments that you made demanding Charlie Webster’s resignation for his similarly “baseless” accusations of us carting bloody Job Corps students around the state, I’d advise you shut your fool mouth.

    Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. If these accusations are false I will be right there calling for her resignation. Somehow, however, I think I’ll wait until Satan is giving free sleigh rides before GOP leadership does the same.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Don’t you even dare. We’re taking this just as seriously as the GOP is. Unless you want to show me the article with the comments that you made demanding Charlie Webster’s resignation for his similarly “baseless” accusations of us carting bloody Job Corps students around the state, I’d advise you shut your fool mouth.

    Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. If these accusations are false I will be right there calling for her resignation. Somehow, however, I think I’ll wait until Satan is giving free sleigh rides before GOP leadership does the same.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Don’t you even dare. We’re taking this just as seriously as the GOP is. Unless you want to show me the article with the comments that you made demanding Charlie Webster’s resignation for his similarly “baseless” accusations of us carting bloody Job Corps students around the state, I’d advise you shut your fool mouth.

    Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. If these accusations are false I will be right there calling for her resignation. Somehow, however, I think I’ll wait until Satan is giving free sleigh rides before GOP leadership does the same.

  • Anonymous

    Downeastvalues, even the usual cadre of libcritters isn’t here to defend her in this thread. This insult will slowly evaporate, courtesy of an obliging media despite the screams and steam being released from the mouths and ears of us indignant, party shirking Mainers.  

  • Anonymous

    Maybe Kevin has been taking some phone tapping lessons from Rupert Murdoch.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe Kevin has been taking some phone tapping lessons from Rupert Murdoch.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe Kevin has been taking some phone tapping lessons from Rupert Murdoch.

  • Anonymous

    The Dems are going off the deep end.  They are so used to running rough shod over the people of Maine with limited opposition that now that they aren’t in power they are apoplectic.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Regina-Hosebeast/100002095287763 Regina Hosebeast

    ” Unlike the Republican Party, we actually take the actions of our party leadership seriously. ”

    Nice diatribe Ed. Is that why Charlie Rangel and Maxine Waters still have their jobs? Rangel was found guilty of ethics violations and I assure you, Waters will as well.

    Sadly for all of us, the murky pools of corruption and immorality run deep on both sides of the political spectrum.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    Maine Democratic Party officials, Regina. Those that local Mainers have control over. I can’t make Charlie Rangel do anything anymore than you can make John Boehner do anything.

  • Anonymous

    Funny how the Republicans react when someone else is doing the spining. The Dems could make up stuff from now until the cows come home and will not have touched the amount of ridiculous blather that has been produced by the extreme wing.

  • Anonymous

    Funny how the Republicans react when someone else is doing the spining. The Dems could make up stuff from now until the cows come home and will not have touched the amount of ridiculous blather that has been produced by the extreme wing.

  • newportres

    So can you make this woman present evidence or resign or is your only contribution to this issue your indignation?
    By the way I flagged your response to the other poster as inappropriate and uncalled for.
    You could try toning it down.

  • Anonymous

    “The woman, who happens to be the secretary for the Maine Democratic Party”

    Yup, nothing more than concerned citizens voicing their relevant nonpartisan views at this public hearing!

  • Anonymous

    “The woman, who happens to be the secretary for the Maine Democratic Party”

    Yup, nothing more than concerned citizens voicing their relevant nonpartisan views at this public hearing!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Edward-Lachowicz/100000535475609 Edward Lachowicz

    It isn’t uncalled for when someone paints with such a broad brush as to accuse all of us as making random baseless accusations. That offended me directly. This behavior is not “typical”.

    That being said, yes, I will be joining others in seeking either evidence or a resignation, as this is either extremely bad form on the part of President Raye, or we have a party leader making false accusations against the other side. Intolerable by Charlie Webster, intolerable now.

    Again, however, I will note that no one of influence in the GOP is calling for Webster’s resignation after he accused us of breaking the law, and Susan Cook didn’t go that far (tape-recording isn’t illegal here).

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • newportres

    Who is the “us” he accused of breaking the law?  I didn’t see him do anything but make vague statements about what he believes he witnessed political activists doing.  Others feel they have seen the same sort of things.
    Did he accuse an individual of doing something and I missed it?
    Maybe you shouldn’t take general political statements so personally. 
    Unless of course you have a reason to be defensive on that topic.

  • Anonymous

    I think she was making fun of whole bunch of Republican activists by accusing one of them, for a change,  of doing what is legal, anyway.  

    LOL

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HJ7QHAWSNLX6Q464TU7IFDN6FQ JohnR

    I am calling for the resignation of Charlie Webster, for the dumbing down of the Republican Party.
    One thing I have learned dealing with Republicans is, there is no need to apologize for accusations of the dirty tricks they play. Geeeeeeeez you can accuse them of just about anything and it will stick. Why…. because if they haven’t already done the dirty trick it is because they haven’t thought of it yet, but rest assured they will. Republican + T’Party = 666……. you do the math. So sad to see this once great party become what it is today, run by treasonous chickenhawk,  anti-patriotic  zealots and evangelical homophobes. Onward Christian soldier.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HJ7QHAWSNLX6Q464TU7IFDN6FQ JohnR

    I am calling for the resignation of Charlie Webster, for the dumbing down of the Republican Party.
    One thing I have learned dealing with Republicans is, there is no need to apologize for accusations of the dirty tricks they play. Geeeeeeeez you can accuse them of just about anything and it will stick. Why…. because if they haven’t already done the dirty trick it is because they haven’t thought of it yet, but rest assured they will. Republican + T’Party = 666……. you do the math. So sad to see this once great party become what it is today, run by treasonous chickenhawk,  anti-patriotic  zealots and evangelical homophobes. Onward Christian soldier.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HJ7QHAWSNLX6Q464TU7IFDN6FQ JohnR

    I am calling for the resignation of Charlie Webster, for the dumbing down of the Republican Party.
    One thing I have learned dealing with Republicans is, there is no need to apologize for accusations of the dirty tricks they play. Geeeeeeeez you can accuse them of just about anything and it will stick. Why…. because if they haven’t already done the dirty trick it is because they haven’t thought of it yet, but rest assured they will. Republican + T’Party = 666……. you do the math. So sad to see this once great party become what it is today, run by treasonous chickenhawk,  anti-patriotic  zealots and evangelical homophobes. Onward Christian soldier.

  • Anonymous

    Ms. Cook,  I am glad you exercised your first amendment right to free speech.  Do not back down and thank you for your good work.  

    Mr Raye is an elected official and he is held to the same standard of libel and slander, as any elected official.  If he is so harmed he has a right to take Ms. Cook to court.  Of course he won’t because he’d lose.  Ms. Cook has every right to her opinion.

    Mr. Webster, We are angry and we know who to blame: You and the Republicans and your dangerous direction.  You are taking away our rights to register and vote, taking away equality for all Maine’s citizens, and now trying to demand someone’s job.  Now you are trying to take a woman’s right to free speech away.

    Mr. Grant you are weak.

  • Anonymous

    got to love these concerned citizen parades the liberals have been tossing up at the last few hearings.Look at the redistricting ,do any of these liberals work or are they all activists.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

  • Anonymous

    Ms C***.

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business