Newport teacher resigns amid allegations kids saw MEA questions

Posted Aug. 05, 2011, at 6:09 p.m.
Last modified Aug. 05, 2011, at 8:31 p.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     

NEWPORT, Maine — A science teacher at Sebasticook Valley Middle School has resigned in wake of allegations he allowed students to review questions on a state standardized test before they took it.

William R. Brooks, a teacher for the school for the last seven years, handed his resignation in Tuesday morning, Regional School Unit 19 Superintendent William Braun said Friday.

Braun confirmed that an investigation conducted by the state was a factor in Brooks’ departure.

According to Braun, Brooks used materials from Maine Educational Assessments distributed in 2009 and 2010, and several students wound up recognizing the exam questions as ones that their teacher reviewed with them before the test.

“The teacher went over all the questions,” Braun said. “That raised a red flag. They reported that with the principal.”

Braun added that some students were puzzled with how easy the exams were, which made administrators even more concerned.

The MEAs are administered to fifth- and eight-graders and are used to chart students’ progress in reading, math and science.

A report released by the Maine Department of Education stated that reliable evidence was found that questions from the MEA science test were disclosed improperly to three of four eighth-grade science classes at the school, according to a report by the Morning Sentinel.

After the concerns were raised, the process of interviewing Brooks’ students subsequently began, and on June 3, Braun said that the Department of Education reviewed the situation and Brooks was placed on administrative leave.

“Since it wasn’t really a high-stakes test, the rationale for doing it — it makes absolutely no sense,” Braun said Friday, referring to the improper disclosure of the test questions.

Telephone messages left for Brooks’ attorney, Howard T. Reben of Portland, and Maine Department of Education Commissioner Stephen Bowen were not returned Friday. Attempts to reach the teacher also were unsuccessful Friday.

Braun said the school is searching for a replacement teacher.

“We’ve had a number of applicants,” he said, adding that he expects the position to be filled when the school board holds its next meeting on Aug. 16.

Brooks is a 1988 graduate of Nokomis Regional High School and coached the boys basketball team at his alma mater for two seasons.

He failed to win a game in his tenure with the Warriors and his contract wasn’t renewed after the 2008-09 season.

Braun said that he wishes Brooks well and he hopes the faculty can move forward.

“There’s certainly lessons to be learned,” Braun said, “not just for him but for all staff.”

“He’s a very bright young man and he has real high expectations for his students,” Braun said in an interview at his Newport office.

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • 525_44

    They’ll need a teacher, there’s one job.

  • Anonymous

    This teacher not only cheated, he taught the children that it was okay to cheat.  And, he receives a severance package (in Lewiston Sun story).  Plus, the Supterintend compliments him, and his name is never mentioned in the investigation so he just goes onto somewhere else to teach.  What is right about this?

  • Anonymous

    This teacher not only cheated, he taught the children that it was okay to cheat.  And, he receives a severance package (in Lewiston Sun story).  Plus, the Supterintend compliments him, and his name is never mentioned in the investigation so he just goes onto somewhere else to teach.  What is right about this?

  • Anonymous

    This teacher not only cheated, he taught the children that it was okay to cheat.  And, he receives a severance package (in Lewiston Sun story).  Plus, the Supterintend compliments him, and his name is never mentioned in the investigation so he just goes onto somewhere else to teach.  What is right about this?

  • Anonymous

    I would like to hear more about the test administrator, typically a principal or lead teacher, who oversaw the testing process.  That person should have known that this teacher was copying previous test material and not just using the released items.  Perhaps the less known, the better!

  • Anonymous

    I would like to hear more about the test administrator, typically a principal or lead teacher, who oversaw the testing process.  That person should have known that this teacher was copying previous test material and not just using the released items.  Perhaps the less known, the better!

  • Anonymous

    I would like to hear more about the test administrator, typically a principal or lead teacher, who oversaw the testing process.  That person should have known that this teacher was copying previous test material and not just using the released items.  Perhaps the less known, the better!

  • Anonymous

    I would like to hear more about the test administrator, typically a principal or lead teacher, who oversaw the testing process.  That person should have known that this teacher was copying previous test material and not just using the released items.  Perhaps the less known, the better!

  • Anonymous

    This teacher was exceptional with his students and he challenged them to look deeper and try harder  My son has signed up for an honors class because of this teacher and he has inspired many students to try harder and he held them accountable to do there work. He made a mistake in life as all of us have done and he is being held accountable. I hope he has the opprotunity to teach again and I am saddened that he will not be teaching my other two son’s.

  • Anonymous

    Was he a coach?

  • Anonymous

    Yes, interesting that the teacher (who should have been canned) is the only person to face consequences. The tests are delivered to the school and must be kept in a secure location by the administration. Why and how did this teacher have access to the tests a day before they were to be given. Where is the follow up article on that?

  • Anonymous

    The real problem here is that the MEAs exist in the first place. If teachers were permitted and encouraged to actually give first place to teaching the subject matter, we would have a nation of reasonably well educated people. This was once the practice and in many respects the public schools didn’t do a half bad job. Today, instead, teachers are forced to spend entirely too much time coaching children how to take tests. The results speak for themselves. 

  • Anonymous

    The real problem here is that the MEAs exist in the first place. If teachers were permitted and encouraged to actually give first place to teaching the subject matter, we would have a nation of reasonably well educated people. This was once the practice and in many respects the public schools didn’t do a half bad job. Today, instead, teachers are forced to spend entirely too much time coaching children how to take tests. The results speak for themselves. 

  • Anonymous

    Yes, god forbid that we know how much our students know from one year to the next. You do realize that standardized tests DO help gauge student progress and guide teachers in helping students with areas of weakness. I think this is a case of a bad apple spoiling the bunch. These tests we give in Maine are not “high-stakes” so this guy had nothing to gain from cheating and nothing to lose if his students did poorly.

  • Anonymous

    Yes, god forbid that we know how much our students know from one year to the next. You do realize that standardized tests DO help gauge student progress and guide teachers in helping students with areas of weakness. I think this is a case of a bad apple spoiling the bunch. These tests we give in Maine are not “high-stakes” so this guy had nothing to gain from cheating and nothing to lose if his students did poorly.

  • Anonymous

    maine, open for business

  • Anonymous

    The operative word is “standardized.” The MEAs change sometimes radically from year to year so comparing tests scores over time tends to be meaningless. The real function of the MEAs is to boost the power of administrators while downgrading that of teachers.

  • Anonymous

    The administration of the either give him the test materials in advance or failed to secure them–either way an administrator shares some responsibility for this.   I wonder if any learning took place? 

  • Anonymous

    “According to Braun, Brooks used materials from Maine Educational
    Assessments distributed in 2009 and 2010, and several students wound up
    recognizing the exam questions as ones that their teacher reviewed with
    them before the test.”

    School districts around the state do this including Bangor.  The MEA provides released items from years past to help students prepare for the types of questioning.  To take 13 and 14 year old’s perspective over the word of the teacher is absurd.  The MEA needs to take a long look at this procedure.  If the MEA’s are a standardized test, should there be standardized preparation?

  • Anonymous

    “According to Braun, Brooks used materials from Maine Educational
    Assessments distributed in 2009 and 2010, and several students wound up
    recognizing the exam questions as ones that their teacher reviewed with
    them before the test.”

    School districts around the state do this including Bangor.  The MEA provides released items from years past to help students prepare for the types of questioning.  To take 13 and 14 year old’s perspective over the word of the teacher is absurd.  The MEA needs to take a long look at this procedure.  If the MEA’s are a standardized test, should there be standardized preparation?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Gweneth-Rodering/100002068408537 Gweneth Rodering

    They release certain questions every year, but they don’t release the whole test!  And half the time the released questions have nothing to do with the actual test material.  He obviously had access to the whole 2009-2010 test.  You probably haven’t even taken the MEAs, so I think I would trust the 13 and 14 year old’s word. 

  • Anonymous

     Assuming I havent taken them is a big assumption.  I am a teacher in Maine, I know the difference.

  • Anonymous

    Sure, its a conspiracy against the teachers. Come on.

  • Anonymous

    good lib. in the classroom.  Next generation will be all set for the potential job market.   

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business