LePage, tribes to explore child welfare abuses

Wabanaki Chiefs, Governor Paul LePage and MITSC Comissioner Denise Altvater signed a decleration of intent on Indian Island Wednesday to start a truth and reconciliation process between the tribes and the state child welfare system. Among the people singning were from left: Governor Joseph Socobasin, Chief Reuben Cleaves, Governor Paul LePage, Chief Kirk Francis.
Wabanaki Chiefs, Governor Paul LePage and MITSC Comissioner Denise Altvater signed a decleration of intent on Indian Island Wednesday to start a truth and reconciliation process between the tribes and the state child welfare system. Among the people singning were from left: Governor Joseph Socobasin, Chief Reuben Cleaves, Governor Paul LePage, Chief Kirk Francis. Buy Photo
Posted May 24, 2011, at 6:53 p.m.
Last modified May 24, 2011, at 8:21 p.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this  

INDIAN ISLAND, Maine — In an effort to move forward from a traumatic past, Maine Indian tribes on Tuesday joined forces with the state of Maine on a project to document the historic experiences of tribal children and families caught up in the state’s child welfare system.

In coming months, members of a special commission will travel to tribal communities throughout the state to encourage individuals and families to recount their experiences, with a goal of improving child welfare services and promoting healing from emotional and spiritual pain.

Gov. Paul LePage visited Indian Island for the first time in many years, signing his name to a document committing his administration to a truth and reconciliation process with the leaders of Maine’s Wabanaki tribes, including the Houlton Band of Maliseets, the Aroostook Band of Micmacs, the Passamaquoddy tribe at Indian Township, the Passamaquoddy tribe at Pleasant Point, and the Penobscot Nation at Indian Island.  

Recalling his own homelessness as a youth, LePage said the project is “long overdue” and that his administration is prepared to support the work of the 18-member Maine State Tribal Truth and Reconciliation Commission. The Maine Indian Tribal State Commission also supports the project.

Although there have been abuses in the past, LePage said, Maine’s child welfare program now is committed to “protecting the rights, dignity and traditions of the tribes while delivering needed services” to all children and families.

“We are one state. We are one people. And we share similar backgrounds,” LePage said. The governor said he visited Indian Island on several occasions years ago when he was a student at Husson College in Bangor, and that he spent 10 years working for a lumber company and “living among the Maliseets” in New Brunswick after graduating.

The goal of the truth and reconciliation project is threefold, according to Passamaquoddy tribe member Esther Attean of the Muskie School of Public Service at the University of Southern Maine in Portland. The project will establish a common understanding of the experience of the Wabanaki people in dealing with the state’s child welfare system, promote emotional and spiritual healing, and improve the delivery of state services to children and families, she said.

According to Wabanaki tradition, “the tribe is the third parent. There is the mother, there is the father, and there is the tribe,” said Attean.  Children wrested from their homes and their culture endure a profound separation that affects the entire community, she said.

Attean said members of the truth and reconciliation commission will visit tribal communities throughout the state to take testimony from individuals and families. The group hopes to issue a report within two years, she said.

Years ago, Penobscot Nation member Denise Yarmal Altvater and her five sisters were taken from their parents’ home and placed with a non-tribal family in Old Town. Altvater, who has been working for a truth and reconciliation process for more than 13 years, said she came to the project “full of childhood memories about the abuse and torture that I suffered in a foster home for four years as a young girl.”

That abuse included ongoing sexual molestation and long overnights locked in the dark, unheated cellar of her foster home, she said.  

“We tried to tell the state what was happening to us, but no one believed us,” she said.

Eventually, the young sisters were placed in a better setting, Altvater said, but no charges were ever brought against the couple that abused them.

Altvater is working with the Philadelphia-based Friends Service Organization, the Muskie School and the Maine Indian State Tribal Commission to help others come to terms with similar experiences.

“Everyone wants to know what the goal of this project it,” Altvater said. “For me, it is about healing, education and learning. It is about changing how we do our work in the future so that every child we are responsible to protect is treated with kindness and dignity and given the best we have to offer so they will have a place that is always safe.”  

Dan Despard, director of child welfare services for the state Department of Health and Human Services, said the state has adopted policies that aim to place children with relatives if their own parents are not able to care for them. When it comes to the children of the Maine Indian tribes, he said, those policies take on added importance.

“We really need to ask if there is a tribal affiliation or native ancestry,” he said. “Even if there is a skipped generation, we give the tribes an opportunity to support the welfare of these children.”

Despard said DHHS case workers now go through special training to “get it into their heads as well as their hearts” that the tribe plays an essential role in foster placement.  

Molly Newell, director of the human services department for the Pleasant Point Passamaquaody tribe, said the tribes “have made great gains” in recent years, working with the state to improve communication and share responsibility for child welfare cases.

“At first, the tribes were reluctant” to participate, she said. “We’ve been burned by the state so many times.” But the process has proven beneficial, she said, with the state providing funding and other forms of support in managing child welfare cases among the Passamaquoddy.

Newell said she believes the truth and reconciliation process will help.

“My hope is to get people to talk about it, so there are no more secrets,” she said.

More information about the Maine Tribal Truth and Reconciliation Commission is available online at www.mainetribaltrc.org.

 

Similar articles:

BDN Marketplace News

Marketplace Businesses

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • KarenLite

    Glad to see this, a new beginning filled with hope for families.  

  • Anonymous

    Way to go!  This is a good start . All children need protection and should be able to remain with a family member if at all possible.   I think LePage is right about this one.

  • Centaurmyst

    What do you know…LePage actually does something right.  

  • hasacluemaine

    I am proud of our Governor working with the First Mainers. Those of French ancestry have always been more prone to empathize with indigenous peoples.  I am not native American, but have seen, heard and felt a very deep, racist Mainer, attitude towards Indians. I do not say all Mainers disrespect the orginal owners of this land, but have seen many who do.

  • ladybaroque

    So glad Gov. Lepage is doing this!

  • Anonymous

    BDN:  Should that be “declaration of intent” under the photo, instead of “decleration”?

  • StillRelaxin

    I sure hope they don’t try to show this horrid history through any form of artwork. We all know how Mayor LePage views artwork showing the hardships children have been forced to suffer here in Maine. Wouldn’t want their stories to be simply stuffed into a closet with everything else he considers trash. People need to learn and they can’t learn when history is hidden from public view or public consciousness.
    ??

  • Anonymous

    Thank you Governor LePage, this is long over due.

  • Anonymous

    I’m proud that  Gov. LePage chose to get involved in this project.  This issue has been a smoking gun for a long time and no other adminstration has taken the time to do anything about it.  Our tribes deserve all the assistance with their child rearing that we’d offer anyone else.  Cheers to you Governor Le Page.

  • Anonymous

    You libs just don’t let go of anything do you?  The whole mural thing was old news weeks ago but you keep banging that same ol’ drum.  Must be from a lack of anything intelligent to say.

  • Jollyroger

    Hold on! Aren’t Native Americans a “special interest group?”

    I didn’t think LePage met with special interests…

    Perhaps he’s seen the light since the Republicans took him to the woodshed?

  • Anonymous

    Hey LePage, tell us once again of your homeless years. 
    Yawn, your still living off the Maine tax payer along with your daughters $41,000 2 hour a day job. 

  • Jollyroger

    I wonder if LePage understands that Maine children from all ethnic backgrounds suffer from abuse and neglect?

    This appears to be a PR ploy, most likely led by Brent Littlefield…a good photo opp…let’s get the Native Americans on our side. Quite suspicious, especially since his approvel number is just 39%….

    When LePage stands (and meets) with all people, and all groups, that will be the day.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYD4MZNHJVHS6VN5XSM63QC3CM Bonny

    Governor LePage has an uncanny knack to understand and be supportive of all Maine residents, not just a chosen few.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe now those Indians will now stop all the complaining about pollution in the Penobscot. You just have to limit the number of fish you eat taken from the river, you can’t eat around that dioxin. Back to the topic, LePage has done it again, right when the Liberals think he is a racist bully he goes and does something not a soul can criticize. Good going LePage, Maine is open for business!

  • Anonymous

    @Lynne14 – Thank you! Something we can all agree on!

  • Anonymous

     This is a lot different than the special interest groups. This is about Maine government not understanding the culture of Native Americans and about a man who finally understands both the harm that was done to their children, and how to start the healing process.

  • Anonymous

     Is that how liberals have worked in the past in Maine? Cater to special interest groups? I read this article as if finally someone is doing what’s right. Period.

  • Anonymous

    This behavior by Lepage goes against core Teaparty values and agenda..are we to believe that Paul Lepage has moved to the center a little and will embrace all Maine people in a similiar way?? I think not.This action is nothing more than desperate act to boost his ratings..I’m glad for these people but they are sitting with a phony pony..

  • Olde Hippie

    Long overdue, the project holds great promise. But I’ll remain on the fence for now; waiting to see if it’s Memorex or if it’s rhetoric. I hope it’s the real thing; I want the Gubnor to get it right this time. (Sorry, Larry, I just can’t bring myself to calling him “The Beloved” just yet.)

  • Anonymous

    Yea, it’s a vast conspiracy encompassing your entire mind………………….once you people climb down off of LePages back he will be able to do many good things for this state none Of which I expect you will acknowledge. That being said, he has managed to do a lot for the taxpayers already. 

  • Anonymous

    LePage has become the “Commission Creator” just
    another group of paid old white guys poking and prodding and basically
    doing nothing but getting paid by the state. Interesting that LePage
    would show interest in child welfare since one of the first actions he
    took in January was getting DHHS to shed a half dozen of their child
    welfare case workers. He didn’t trim any supervisory positions, just the
    people who actually do the work.

  • Anonymous

    You are absolutely right about Maine’s racist attitude. Against our native Mainers, and any group that comes to the state from anywhere else. If you don’t look, talk or think alike you are treated as an outsider. Don’t hold your breath for help from LePage though, he’s all smiles and grins when signing the papers, but all he does is create commissions and do studies. This is nothing but glad handing and passing out money to his pals to poke and prod people. They’ll be nothing to come of this but a report to be tossed on the stack with the rest,

  • Anonymous

    One hand giveth as the other hand taketh away!

  • Anonymous

    That trip to the woodshed was a just public whipping!!!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IBNCEJ2CDT4I4T4KLVIIXRI7YA Mandy & LiLi

    Ha ha ha- what Maine do you live in? 

  • Anonymous

     Excellent, finally help for children!  Can we get going on addressing the plight of our elderly next?

  • Anonymous

    Considering the support expressed for LePage, I think that answer should be apparent. 

  • Anonymous

    She must live in the part where the estate tax exemption just got quintupled.Lucky girl.

  • Anonymous

    Wheres the TB crowd crying foul because LePage might spend state money
    to help kids of what is (from my understanding) a separate and sovereign
    nation? Where are the cries of ‘Y U NO HAVE MOAR PERSONAL
    RESPONSIBILITY?” Where are the accusations of this being a potential way to get more voters on state aid?

    If this were Baldacci, there would be a lot of wailing and gnashing of teeth going on this morning.

  • Anonymous

    Not to mention food stamps,heating assistance and trying to cut Medicaid from the very poorest in the 2012-13 and 2013-14 budget.I guess those kids and families don’t matter.

  • Anonymous

    If he really wanted to find some abused kids,he could go to Rome and hang with the pedophiles.
    Must be almost time for another vacation.

  • Anonymous

    “We are one state. We are one people.” Ok. Then why oh why do they get special treatment…like free hunting and fishing licences? Why do they get 25 trap recreational licences? If we are ONE people, then I want MY clam licence for five dollars.

  • Anonymous

    Gov. Baldacci started this process and gave Lepage the opportunity to complete it. You can confirm this by asking any member of the MITSC group.  Why does everything have to have a political slant attached to it?  You are the racist here with your opening comment.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe now  those white people will now stop complaining about the Natives complaining about pollution  in the Penobscot.    Does this sound racist to you?

  • Anonymous

    Sounds like someone is not a happy camper.   Natives always had aboriginal rights to hunt and fish for sustenance on their lands.   Encroachment of land and waters inhibited this.  This is forged out of the erosion of Native rights as first inhabitants of this state. 

  • Anonymous

     Native history is already “simply stuffed”.  Case in point,  LD 291 is a law requiring that Wabanaki studies be integrated and taught in Maine’s K-8 classrooms. For the most part, this is not happening but we teach spanish, french, cival rights, Martin Luther KIng, etc. and yes, the ignorant perpetuation of the false belief that Good old Columbus discovered America. 

  • Anonymous

    Its not just those on entitlement programs who are poor anymore. This has been broadened to include the working poor and more and more “middle class” families.  We should not cut entitlement programs for those truly in need.  If you are capable of working then you should not be receiving welfare.  Maine’s welfare rates/costs are out of control.  We can no longer afford the costs.

  • Anonymous

    Considering what we got out of our dealings with the natives, I’m pretty sure we came out ahead. Maybe if the state decides to take everything you own (and take away most of your civil rights for 100 years or so), you can get a $5 clam license too!

  • Anonymous

    Nothing is ever politically correct enough for you is it? The statement is a little rough, but I fail to see how it’s racist.

  • Anonymous

    Let’s sure hope not.

  • Anonymous

    He is a real shill. I would ignore him.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t even try and figure that one out!  I don’t anymore. The inconsistencies are glaring.

  • Anonymous

    Racist, I don’t think so I happen to be 1/16 Indian. While I have never lived on the “rez” I have had to live with the Indian stigma my entire life, which it shouldn’t be. Anyways, racism doesn’t exist in this country any more albeit a few fringe loons, and I am not talking about the duck species. We have a a President of color and possible muslim heritage in the White House. If racism existed here in the USA he would have never been elected. That is not racist but a mainstream belief.  

  • Anonymous

    Lynne14, you are a real peach but let us leave the name calling to the elementary school students.

  • Anonymous

    Couldn’t agree more Haddock Burger! Special treatment must end, but the real deal here is LePage is placating the left and Indians so Maine can be more business friendly. It is sad it has to work like that but it does. Politics is a funny game but LePage is playing it well.

  • Anonymous

    Please, Stone … just name THREE!

  • Anonymous

    I will absolutely agree that there are some who beat the system.There have also been a number of high profile cases of people going to prison or at least having their assets confiscated etc.for defrauding the state,feds or both .Nothing makes me happier.But I’m still waiting for some Wall Streeters to join Bernie  Madoff in his cell.I doubt that will happen anytime soon.

  • Anonymous

    It was very moving to see this take place. Though I haven’t been an avid supporter of LePage, I must say that he comes off differently in person than he is portrayed by the media. He seemed sincere in his remarks and demeanor. I saw a side of him that I haven’t seen. I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt and believe that he was sincere until I find out otherwise. 

    For those of us ripped away from our cultural heritage/spiritual foundation at birth and placed in non-native homes, this was a monumental day. It is the start of the healing process and the foundation has been laid that the children of this generation will not be stripped away from their cultural/spiritual foundation.

  • StillRelaxin

    You don’t know how sad it is that I’ve never heard of this.  Also sad is that almost no one here “likes” to be informed of LD 291.  I for one will check it out, “liked” your comment and will try to use it to further the education of those I may come into contact with.  Those of a conservative bent, well you might just as well have been trying to educate a stone wall.

  • Anonymous

    When a government makes a treaty with a group of people to assign them land, hunting and fishing rights, those rights don’t go away after a couple of generations. A contract is a contract and no amount of time makes that contract null and void.

    Governor LePage really didn’t to anything for this project. He merely came, said a few words and enjoyed a photo op. The real work was done and will be done by Native people. He merely agreed that this is important work to do so that Native children stay in Native homes and are raised within the culture.

  • Anonymous

    Here are my feelings on our Child Welfare. We have looked into many Departments and feel it is time to look into the Child Welfare in Township. I have seen first hand what they are capable of doing and making up  their own RULES as they see fit for them. I also see that UNITING the Families is not TOP PRIORITY! Other Departments have been looked into and i feel it is time to see what is really happening in that Department as well. Hate to think that they (Child Welfare) may not be following the proper procedures. ALWAYS remember we have RIGHTS and they (CHILD WELFARE) our Child Welfare should be here to work for us not against us.

  • Anonymous

     Here are my feelings on our Child Welfare. We have looked into many Departments and feel it is time to look into the Child Welfare in Township. I have seen first hand what they are capable of doing and making up their own RULES as they see fit for them. I also see that UNITING the Families is not TOP PRIORITY! Other Departments have been looked into and i feel it is time to see what is really happening in that Department as well. Hate to think that they (Child Welfare) may not be following the proper procedures. ALWAYS remember we have RIGHTS and they (CHILD WELFARE) our Child Welfare should be here to work for us not against us.

  • Anonymous

    After my Experince with Indian  Township Child Welfare, Being Native myself, I rather work with the State Child Welfare. Seems to me that we are not touching bases with what is really happening among our own Departments. That is SAD!

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

BDN Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business
ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business