May 22, 2019
Portland Latest News | Geraldine Largay | Bangor Metro | Mills Revived | Today's Paper

Jury begins deliberation in case of Augusta couple’s Christmas slaying

Jake Bleiberg | BDN
Jake Bleiberg | BDN
David Marble (right) confers with his attorney, Jon Gale, in a Portland courtroom on Wednesday. Marble is charged in connection with a 2015 Christmas morning shooting deaths of an Augusta couple.

The fate of a man accused of killing an Augusta couple on Christmas in 2015 now rests with a Cumberland County jury.

Arguments in David Marble Jr.’s trial for the murder of Eric Williams and Bonnie Royer finished around noon Wednesday, after more than a week of testimony. By around 5 p.m., the jury had not yet reached a verdict, and Justice Michaela Murphy dismissed them for the day.

During closing arguments, a prosecutor told the jury that witness testimony corroborated by data from Marble’s cellphone and physical evidence from the scene of the shooting requires them to return a guilty verdict.

A defense attorney, however, said that there is no evidence that Marble pulled the trigger and said that the state’s argument in the case — which was part of a controversy over racially charged comments by Gov. Paul LePage — was based on “bluster and horror.”

Jake Bleiberg | BDN
Jake Bleiberg | BDN
David Marble sits in a Portland courtroom Wednesday. Marble is charged in connection with a 2015 Christmas morning shooting deaths of an Augusta couple.

On Christmas morning 2015, Williams, 35, and Royer, 26, were each shot dead at a gravel pit less than a mile from their home. Marble, 32, of Rochester, New York, pleaded not guilty to the murders but prosecutors contend that he killed them in retaliation for a robbery of his apartment. He could face life in prison if found guilty.

[Man charged with murder in Christmas slaying of Augusta couple]

In 2017, Marble’s case was moved from Kennebec County to a Portland court after LePage referenced him in public statement, saying drug dealers with names such as “D-Money, Smoothie and Shifty” come to Maine and sometimes impregnate “young white girl[s].”

The comments were condemned as bigoted in Maine and nationally. Lawyers on both side have largely avoided using Marble’s nickname, D-Money, during the trial and in court filings.

On Wednesday, prosecutor Lisa Marchese and defense attorney Jon Gale agreed that a central element of the case was testimony of Timothy Bragg, who allegedly gave Marble a ride to the crime scene on the night of the killings and later became a witness against him.

Both sides likewise agreed that in 2015 Bragg made false statements to police. But they broke on the reason for that, with Marchese saying that he didn’t initially say all he knew against Marble out of fear of the man, while Gale said that his later statements were led by police.

Jake Bleiberg | BDN
Jake Bleiberg | BDN
David Marble (right) and his lawyer, Jon Gale, are seen in a Portland courtroom Wednesday. Marble is charged in connection with a 2015 Christmas morning shooting deaths of an Augusta couple.

In closing arguments and during the trial, Gale also suggested that Bragg’s testimony, and that of other state witnesses who were given immunity in the case, was colored by racial bias. Marchese dismissed this notion Wednesday.

“Bonnie Royer and Eric Williams were executed,” Marchese told the jury, raising her hand to point at Marble sitting feet away. “They were executed by this man, David Marble, in retribution for the burglary at his apartment.”

“The evidence, the hard evidence, does not support that he pulled the trigger,” Gale, later told the jury, stressing that the state’s case does not rise above the legal standard of reasonable doubt.

The jury is scheduled to resume deliberation at 8:30 a.m. Thursday.

Follow the Bangor Daily News on Facebook for the latest Maine news.

Correction: This story previously misquoted a single word of lawyer Jon Gale’s closing argument. He said the state’s case was “bluster.”


Have feedback? Want to know more? Send us ideas for follow-up stories.

You may also like