Inmate charged with manslaughter in 2009 death of another prisoner

Posted July 14, 2011, at 8:11 p.m.
Last modified July 15, 2011, at 9:50 a.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     

WARREN, Maine — A Maine State Prison inmate has been indicted on a manslaughter charge in connection with the death of another inmate at the prison two years ago.

John Thibeault, 32, formerly of Brewer and Orono, was indicted by the Knox County grand jury on Thursday.

The indictment, which did not offer much detail, indicates that “Thibeault did recklessly or with criminal negligence cause the death of Sheldon Weinstein,” who was 64 when he died in the Maine State Prison in April 2009.

Weinstein, who used a wheelchair, died of blunt force injuries suffered at the hands of other inmates, according to Bangor Daily News reports at the time. Within days of his death, Maine State Police were investigating the case as a homicide.

Weinstein’s wife’s attorney said in June that he expected multiple indictments of prisoners in relation to what he called an assault on Weinstein that led to his death.

In 2009, Weinstein’s wife,Janet, threatened a $1 million wrongful death lawsuit against the prison. That remains a possibility, attorney Scott Gardner told the BDN last month. He said he continues to negotiate with the state concerning the case.

Maine Department of Corrections Associate Commissioner Jody Breton confirmed that Thibeault is a prisoner but could not give any other information about the alleged crime.

According to a criminal record obtained electronically Thursday night from the Maine State Bureau of Identification, Thibeault is serving a 15-year sentence for a 1997 robbery. Thibeault, who has a tattoo of a peace sign on his leg and a joker on his back, was only supposed to serve six years of the sentence but he has had his probation revoked several times for undisclosed reasons, which has kept him in prison.

One prison employee was fired and another was demoted in connection with Weinstein’s death, according to BDN archives.

No other details were immediately available about Thursday’s indictment. Neither Gardner nor Bill Stokes, chief of the Maine attorney general’s criminal division, could be reached for comment late Thursday.

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • Anonymous

    Ahh, come on now. Everyone knows that it couldn’t have been a fellow inmate. It had to have been a guard.

  • PaulNotBunyan

    Is there some reason this story tells us why the accused is in prison but fails to mention why the dead man was there? I’m sure he wasn’t there voluntarily for a vacation or something. Will the grieving widow also sue the newspaper if they add a few minor details to this story? I just want to be sure that he wasn’t put in there without first being convicted of some felony. But wait a minute. I think I remember why he was sent there ….

  • PaulNotBunyan

    Is there some reason this story tells us why the accused is in prison but fails to mention why the dead man was there? I’m sure he wasn’t there voluntarily for a vacation or something. Will the grieving widow also sue the newspaper if they add a few minor details to this story? I just want to be sure that he wasn’t put in there without first being convicted of some felony. But wait a minute. I think I remember why he was sent there ….

  • PaulNotBunyan

    Is there some reason this story tells us why the accused is in prison but fails to mention why the dead man was there? I’m sure he wasn’t there voluntarily for a vacation or something. Will the grieving widow also sue the newspaper if they add a few minor details to this story? I just want to be sure that he wasn’t put in there without first being convicted of some felony. But wait a minute. I think I remember why he was sent there ….

  • Anonymous

    You probably do…. click on the Blunt Force Injuries   link to learn if you remember correctly.

  • PaulNotBunyan

    How about that! I did remember correctly.

  • PaulNotBunyan

    How about that! I did remember correctly.

  • Xerxies

    I  find it very difficult to find any sympathy whatsoever for Weinstein, or his wife… 

  • Anonymous

    “At the time of his death, Weinstein — a diabetic — was serving a two-year sentence for a conviction of one count of gross sexual assault against a child”

    http://bangordailynews.com/2009/12/04/politics/state-may-face-1m-wrongful-death-lawsuit/

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Regina-Hosebeast/100002095287763 Regina Hosebeast

    Weinstein may have been a bottom feeder and most of us despise the wrist-slapping sentences handed out by some of our judges, but justice belongs in the courtroom, not in a jail cell. This reeks of “The inmates are running the asylum”. We are in a sad state if we depend on prisoners in Warren to mete out the punishment that our justice system can’t seem to handle.

    I suspect the prison employee that was fired had some knowledge of what was going on during this incident. In addition to being fired, he or she should be held responsible to some degree for the death. Weinstein’s wife will win the lawsuit, but I suspect she will settle with the State for an undisclosed amount, out of court.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Regina-Hosebeast/100002095287763 Regina Hosebeast

    Weinstein may have been a bottom feeder and most of us despise the wrist-slapping sentences handed out by some of our judges, but justice belongs in the courtroom, not in a jail cell. This reeks of “The inmates are running the asylum”. We are in a sad state if we depend on prisoners in Warren to mete out the punishment that our justice system can’t seem to handle.

    I suspect the prison employee that was fired had some knowledge of what was going on during this incident. In addition to being fired, he or she should be held responsible to some degree for the death. Weinstein’s wife will win the lawsuit, but I suspect she will settle with the State for an undisclosed amount, out of court.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Regina-Hosebeast/100002095287763 Regina Hosebeast

    Weinstein may have been a bottom feeder and most of us despise the wrist-slapping sentences handed out by some of our judges, but justice belongs in the courtroom, not in a jail cell. This reeks of “The inmates are running the asylum”. We are in a sad state if we depend on prisoners in Warren to mete out the punishment that our justice system can’t seem to handle.

    I suspect the prison employee that was fired had some knowledge of what was going on during this incident. In addition to being fired, he or she should be held responsible to some degree for the death. Weinstein’s wife will win the lawsuit, but I suspect she will settle with the State for an undisclosed amount, out of court.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Regina-Hosebeast/100002095287763 Regina Hosebeast

    Weinstein may have been a bottom feeder and most of us despise the wrist-slapping sentences handed out by some of our judges, but justice belongs in the courtroom, not in a jail cell. This reeks of “The inmates are running the asylum”. We are in a sad state if we depend on prisoners in Warren to mete out the punishment that our justice system can’t seem to handle.

    I suspect the prison employee that was fired had some knowledge of what was going on during this incident. In addition to being fired, he or she should be held responsible to some degree for the death. Weinstein’s wife will win the lawsuit, but I suspect she will settle with the State for an undisclosed amount, out of court.

  • yowsayowsa1

    Except if you are a lawyer!

  • yowsayowsa1

    Except if you are a lawyer!

  • Anonymous

    If that is the case….he got what was coming~

  • Anonymous

    If that is the case….he got what was coming~

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RX23W5V7A2J6BYTBB3MZJE5ZKA Jeff D

    With tongue in cheek, I would like to know what you think is wrong with ‘Bubba- justice’ when nearly all comments are about any man going to jail for any heinous crime will receive his justice when ‘Bubba’ gets hold of him. I think instead of letting them all off on insanity convictions we should send some of those heifers into the women’s prisons to mete out justice before we begin to clean up Warren.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RX23W5V7A2J6BYTBB3MZJE5ZKA Jeff D

    With tongue in cheek, I would like to know what you think is wrong with ‘Bubba- justice’ when nearly all comments are about any man going to jail for any heinous crime will receive his justice when ‘Bubba’ gets hold of him. I think instead of letting them all off on insanity convictions we should send some of those heifers into the women’s prisons to mete out justice before we begin to clean up Warren.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RX23W5V7A2J6BYTBB3MZJE5ZKA Jeff D

    With tongue in cheek, I would like to know what you think is wrong with ‘Bubba- justice’ when nearly all comments are about any man going to jail for any heinous crime will receive his justice when ‘Bubba’ gets hold of him. I think instead of letting them all off on insanity convictions we should send some of those heifers into the women’s prisons to mete out justice before we begin to clean up Warren.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RX23W5V7A2J6BYTBB3MZJE5ZKA Jeff D

    With tongue in cheek, I would like to know what you think is wrong with ‘Bubba- justice’ when nearly all comments are about any man going to jail for any heinous crime will receive his justice when ‘Bubba’ gets hold of him. I think instead of letting them all off on insanity convictions we should send some of those heifers into the women’s prisons to mete out justice before we begin to clean up Warren.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RX23W5V7A2J6BYTBB3MZJE5ZKA Jeff D

    With tongue in cheek, I would like to know what you think is wrong with ‘Bubba- justice’ when nearly all comments are about any man going to jail for any heinous crime will receive his justice when ‘Bubba’ gets hold of him. I think instead of letting them all off on insanity convictions we should send some of those heifers into the women’s prisons to mete out justice before we begin to clean up Warren.

  • Karen

    That’s what happens to to convicted sexual offenders in Prison. Hello!!!! 

  • Karen

    That’s what happens to to convicted sexual offenders in Prison. Hello!!!! 

  • Karen

    That’s what happens to to convicted sexual offenders in Prison. Hello!!!! 

  • Karen

    That’s what happens to to convicted sexual offenders in Prison. Hello!!!! 

  • Karen

    That’s what happens to to convicted sexual offenders in Prison. Hello!!!! 

  • Karen

    That’s what happens to to convicted sexual offenders in Prison. Hello!!!! 

  • Anonymous

    Maybe all she did wrong was marrying the wrong man.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe all she did wrong was marrying the wrong man.

  • Anonymous

     Too bad the system seeks ways to unlock the doors on the very people who need to be locked away.

  • Anonymous

     Too bad the system seeks ways to unlock the doors on the very people who need to be locked away.

  • Anonymous

    and your point is what…I was replying to someone else………good grief

  • Anonymous

    and your point is what…I was replying to someone else………good grief

  • Anonymous

    If she does sue and win…kills me that’s a possibility… I hope the his victim sues his estate and wins.

  • Anonymous

    If she does sue and win…kills me that’s a possibility… I hope the his victim sues his estate and wins.

  • Anonymous

    If she does sue and win…kills me that’s a possibility… I hope the his victim sues his estate and wins.

  • Anonymous

    If she does sue and win…kills me that’s a possibility… I hope the his victim sues his estate and wins.

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business