SHARON, Massachusetts — For a year, Michelle Pepe awoke every day, recited the Kaddish, the mourner’s prayer, and kissed a photo of her father. And coped with her guilt.
“‘Dad,” she said, “I’m so sorry that this happened.”
“This” was COVID-19. In March 2020, just as the pandemic bloomed in the United States, Pepe traveled from Boston to Florida for her mother’s 80th birthday. She believes she gave the coronavirus to her father, Bernie Rubin, who died weeks later.
“At the beginning, people would say, ‘Well, how did he get it?’ From me. That’s how he got it — he got it from me,” Pepe said, sobbing.
“Nobody’s ever said, ‘This is your fault and you gave it to him,’ but I know it’s true. I know I couldn’t save him. It’s just something I’m going to have to go to the grave with.”
Hers is a common sorrow of the times. Around the world, countless people are struggling to shake off the burden of feeling responsible for the death of a loved one due to COVID-19. They regret a trip or feel anguish over everyday decisions that may have spread the disease — commuting to work, hugging parents, even picking up food.
On the eve of the anniversary of her father’s death, Pepe’s hands trembled as she held a framed portrait of Bernie and Phyllis Rubin, smiling and surrounded by their 10 grandchildren. Taken on March 8, 2020, it’s one of the last images of the couple with their family.
After the celebration, Pepe stayed in Florida to take care of them during the pandemic. She believes she caught the virus while shopping for groceries for her parents. Then her father and mother sickened. Worried about his worsening condition, she called 911. He died alone at Delray Medical Center; family members were unable to visit him.
“I shouldn’t have given up and called the ambulance,” she said. “That’s what haunts me, and thinking about him, alone in that room … I know he was terrified.”
There was just a brief, socially distanced graveside burial. Pepe watched on Zoom while she continued to care for her mother, who has multiple sclerosis and was recovering from COVID-19.
Pepe has been battling despair ever since.
“I was in a real funk for a real long time,” she said. “And then one of my daughters said to me, ‘Mommy, we thought that we lost our grandfather, but … we didn’t realize we also lost our mom.’ I figured I have to snap out of it.”
Pepe joined online support groups where she met other grieving survivors; went to a psychic medium, searching for signs; and sought guidance from a rabbi who taught her how to recite the Kaddish.
On April 13, she awoke to say the prayer and light a yahrzeit candle marking the anniversary of her father’s death. “We just have to get through this day,” she repeated on the drive to the cemetery. She wore her father’s gold chain and high school graduation ring.
At his grave, she placed yellow flowers on a tombstone that reads: “Loving husband, father, pup” — his nickname — “and great grandfather.” In the Jewish tradition, family members leave behind small stones.
They remember a man who adored his grandchildren, calling them daily to catch up on the latest Red Sox news or to invite them to games at Fenway Park. In recent years, “he couldn’t walk very fast — unless it was for a baseball game. Then he’d turn into Carl Lewis!” said Bob Pepe, Michelle’s husband, who worked with his father-in-law and remained his close friend for 30 years.
The furniture store that Rubin founded with his wife in 1983 grew into the Bernie & Phyl’s Furniture chain, with nine locations across New England.
The couple were featured in TV commercials best-known for their catchy jingle. Strangers would often recognize them at restaurants and recite the catchphrase: “Oh, are you Bernie from Bernie and Phyl’s, quality, comfort and price?”
And Bernie Rubin would chime in, as in the ads: “That’s nice!”
After the cemetery, Pepe visited the company’s headquarters in Norton. She admired the walls adorned with hundreds of autographed photos of baseball players her dad began collecting as a kid. She took a deep breath and walked into his office, decorated with another, equally prized collection: photos of his family on cruise vacations, at bar mitzvahs, college graduations and weddings.
She picked up her dad’s work phone, leaning in close to take a whiff as she often does with his wallet, his shirts and his cologne, hoping to sense his presence. But she smelled nothing — COVID-19 robbed her of her senses of smell and taste.
At lunch, the family walks to Rubin’s favorite restaurant and orders the “Bernie Reuben,” a sandwich named after him. Every day, Rubin would walk into Kelly’s Place to order a cheese omelet and go through the same comedic routine with a waitress.
“‘Carol, I have to stand here for 20 minutes? There’s 10 empty tables. How do you run a business like this?'” Bob Pepe said, imitating Bernie’s voice. “And she’d go: ‘Will you shut up? You know where you’re sitting, go sit down!'”
Sitting next to her husband, Michelle Pepe burst into laughter. Later, she wiped away tears.
“It was torture,” she said. “But a year later, here I am, and I can laugh at these stories.”
The next day, she awoke to kiss her father’s photo. She looked at the calendar and heaved a sigh of relief. The ritual year of mourning is over.
“My father would be so tortured if he thought about how tortured I was, and I want him to be happy and at peace,” she said. “And he’s only going to be that way if I’m that way here.”
Story by Luis Andres Henao and Jessie Wardarski.