Newcastle Assessors’ Agent Jim Murphy makes his recommendation to the Newcastle Board of Selectmen against an abatement request from Lincoln Academy for eight dorm parent apartments. Credit: Evan Houk | Lincoln County News

The Newcastle Board of Selectmen voted 4-0 to deny Lincoln Academy’s request for an abatement of property taxes for eight dorm parent apartments Oct. 28.

Lincoln Academy’s head of school, Jeffrey Burroughs, and Chief Financial Officer Wendy Corlett met with the selectmen to discuss the issue on Oct. 28.

Burroughs said the school believes its dorm parent apartments should be exempt from taxes under state law because they provide “necessary services and facilities” that further the school’s tax-exempt mission as a literary and scientific institution.

The selectmen based their decision on the recommendation of Newcastle Assessors’ Agent Jim Murphy, who said the matter has not been interpreted and decided above the local level yet and should be left to the state.

“It would be beneficial to find out if housing for parents that are required to be on-site is taxable,” Murphy said.

Board Chair Ben Frey agreed.

“The interpretation is not clear, nor do I honestly feel like it is the role of either the applicant or the town to be interpreting at that level. Our job should be more the fair application of the law,” Frey said.

Murphy recommended that Newcastle start taxing the eight residences in question June 10.

In June 2015, Murphy assessed the apartments at $726,900 and taxed the school $13,120.55. Murphy had determined that the apartments in the new Kiah Bayley Hall, which opened in February 2015, and existing apartments in Hall House were taxable, even though the majority of the campus is tax-exempt.

Lincoln Academy’s head of school at the time, David Sturdevant, filed an abatement request on behalf of the school Dec. 21, 2015, which the selectmen granted Feb. 15, 2016.

Frey said at the June 10 meeting that the town had only abated, not exempted, the taxes for the staff apartments for one year, in 2016, and simply never ended the abatement.

Burroughs pointed to his own residence, Borland Hall, as an example of a taxable building used primarily for employee housing. Borland Hall has always been taxed by Newcastle.

Burroughs also pointed to the Maine Supreme Judicial Court’s 2013 ruling in Hebron Academy, Inc. v. Town of Hebron, which he said set a precedent dealing with a similar situation.

Frey said the selectmen discussed that case with the town’s attorney and were advised to bring the issue to a higher authority for clarification.

This story appears through a media partnership with The Lincoln County News.