August 24, 2019
Contributors Latest News | Blue Hill Mansions | Bangor Metro | Colonial Fort | Today's Paper

Trump’s transgender military ban is far more cruel than you realize

A rainbow flag flies as people protest U.S. President Donald Trump's announcement that he plans to reinstate a ban on transgender individuals from serving in any capacity in the U.S. military, in Times Square, in New York City, New York, U.S., July 26, 2017.

When President Donald Trump casually ordered the Pentagon on Wednesday to ban transgender service members from the military, he didn’t just undo months of work by military officers, civilian policymakers and trans advocacy groups. He also cut off transgender Americans from an institution that’s historically been viewed as a microcosm of society — and a bastion of steady employment. The effects of Trump’s shocking strike against the trans rights movement could be much more severe than anyone realized initially.

By some estimates, the U.S. military is the single largest employer of transgender people on the planet, with an estimated 15,500 active-duty trans personnel. Trans people are twice as likely than the general population to serve their country, according to the study “Still Serving in Silence: Transgender Service Members and Veterans in the National Transgender Discrimination Survey,” by Jack Harrison-Quintana, policy institute manager at the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, and Jody Herman, manager of transgender research at the Williams Institute. That’s partly because transgender Americans are patriots just like cisgender Americans, but it’s also partly because we still run far behind our cisgender peers in access to education, affordable housing and employment.

[I served 34 years in the Army. I’m transgender. President Trump is wrong.]

Trump’s order means thousands of trans people won’t be able to turn to the military in search of a career anymore. And with his Department of Justice filing a federal court brief asserting that discrimination on the basis of gender identity is legal, the situation for trans Americans will only get worse. Trans people in America have an unemployment rate of 15 percent, three times higher than the general population. We don’t need righteous anti-Trump rants — we need jobs.

It remains to be seen whether the administration will decide to discharge all trans servicemembers, as the Pentagon stated Thursday it would wait for official White House policy before moving forward, leaving trans people currently serving in place for now. If they return to the old policy under “don’t ask, don’t tell” at some point down the road, trans troops would be receiving general discharges marked “mentally unfit for duty.” As a result, they wouldn’t be able to access any veterans’ benefits, including the VA health care system or education credits. Troops who did nothing but dare to serve their country openly will be thrown out on the streets with a record that harms their future job prospects. The Trump ban is unnecessarily cruel to our fine trans people in uniform.

[Degradation by tweet is no way to run the US military]

What are the thousands of trans troops currently serving supposed to do, exactly? Many of them were encouraged to begin the process of coming out by the previous administration, and now Trump is firing them. Trump’s decision appears to be completely motivated by electoral politics. According to Axios, a Trump administration source said the ban “forces Democrats in Rust Belt states like Ohio, Michigan and Wisconsin to take complete ownership of this issue. How will the blue-collar voters in these states respond when senators up for reelection in 2018 like Debbie Stabenow are forced to make their opposition to this a key plan of their campaigns?”

I hope those blue-collar voters take a look at how much time, money and other resources were spent studying the readiness and economic impact of allowing trans troops to serve and wonder why their president fired more than 15,000 brave trans people in uniform to play electoral politics at the expense of one of the most underprivileged demographics in the country. Being able to enlist for military service is the bare minimum of effort at trans inclusiveness.

Trump promised jobs, and he promised to support lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer people; instead, he’s selling us out for votes. In Trump’s America, trans people can’t serve in the military, we don’t deserve employment protections and we’re not welcome in schools. But we’re still people, we’re still Americans. Where do we fit in American society? Well, the president gave his answer: We don’t.

Katelyn Burns is an essayist and a trans woman. She lives in Maine with her two young children.


Have feedback? Want to know more? Send us ideas for follow-up stories.

You may also like