June 19, 2018
Nation Latest News | Poll Questions | Susan Collins | Tiny House Surprise | Stephen King

Poor households take lead in abandoning land lines

Bridget Brown | BDN FILE
Bridget Brown | BDN FILE
By Nomaan Merchant and Alan Fram, The Associated Press

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. — In a financial and technological role reversal, a growing number of Americans are getting rid of their old telephones and using only cell phones, a trend being led not by the high-tech elite but by people in poorer states as a way to save money.

Government estimates released Wednesday show at least 30 percent of adults in 10 states rely entirely on cell phones, with the highest percentage in Arkansas and Mississippi, where many cannot afford to pay for two separate lines.

Wealthier households have been slower to use wireless technology as their sole means of making calls.

“The answer’s obvious: No one has money here,” said John N. Daigle, a professor of electrical engineering at the University of Mississippi with broad experience in the telecommunications industry. “If they can do without a land line, they’ll do it to save money.”

William Phillips of North Little Rock says he grew tired of paying for a land line his family rarely used. So he and his wife dumped their old phone and now have prepaid cell phones that cost a total of $75 a month.

Phillips, a 39-year-old commercial pilot, taught his 12-year-old son, who doesn’t have a phone, how to email him rather than call when the boy is at home.

“I’ve heard people talk about it, that they ought to do it,” Phillips said. “They’re just hanging onto that phone number.”

About 35 percent of adults in Arkansas and Mississippi have only cell phones, according to figures from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

In New Jersey and Rhode Island, the states where the smallest proportion of people depend strictly on wireless phones, that figure is only 13 percent.

Mississippi has the highest poverty rate in the nation — 21.9 percent in 2009, according to the Census Bureau. The Arkansas figure was 18.8 percent. The nationwide rate is 14.3 percent.

In 2009, the Census Bureau defined poverty as a single person making less than $11,000 a year or a family of four making less than $22,000 a year.

“I think people decide, ‘I can afford one but not the other,’” said Ellen Reddy, who works for a nonprofit community center that helps low-income residents in Holmes County, Miss. She said poor people in her area often have cell phones with a limited number of minutes.

“When the minutes are gone, oftentimes we can’t reach our families,” Reddy said. “I think people are making choices.”

The number of American households that rely exclusively on cell phones has been growing steadily nationwide, hitting 27 percent in the first half of 2010, an eightfold increase in just six years. Arkansas has had the greatest increase, with 15 percentage points. New Jersey’s 7 percentage-point growth was the lowest.

Donielle Flowers of Little Rock doesn’t remember the last time she had a land line. She’s chosen to carry one of two cell phones — a free, government-subsidized phone with 250 minutes a month, and a prepaid phone that costs $60 a month.

“It’s an extra bill,” Flowers, 34, said of land lines. “I’m rarely at home, so I just need a cell phone. I’d be lost without it.”

That matches the conclusion of Stephen Blumberg, a senior CDC scientist and an author of the survey. Over the years, Blumberg has found that lower-income people are more likely than higher-earning Americans to have only wireless phones. Younger people and renters are also quicker to shed traditional land lines.

New Jersey is neither young nor poor, and that’s keeping it at the bottom of the list, Blumberg said.

On Wednesday, many people walking around the capital city of Trenton were talking on cell phones or texting family, friends and colleagues. Among them was Harry Weaver, a 46-year-old insurance agent who said he loves the freedom and convenience his smartphone provides.

Weaver acknowledged that he “pretty much lives” on his smartphone but said he has no plans to pull the plug on his home land line.  As the father of three teenage daughters, Weaver says he wants a “dependable” phone line in case his girls need to reach their parents in an emergency.

“We could probably end our land line service and save some money, but it gives me peace of mind to know there’s another way they can reach us if needed,” Weaver said.

Some customers feel land lines offer more security, especially if they ever need to call 911. Since wireless phones are not linked to a fixed address, the caller’s location can be more difficult for dispatchers to pinpoint.

The latest state-by-state figures, which cover the 12 months through June 2010, may indicate changes are needed in the way some public opinion polls are conducted, Blumberg said.

As the use of cell phones has grown, major pollsters have routinely included cell-phone users in the people they call randomly. The number of cell-phone users they call reflects national cell-phone use, but Wednesday’s findings suggest those numbers may need adjustment in states with especially high or low cell phone dependence, he said.

In addition to those in Arkansas and Mississippi, at least 30 percent of adults in eight other states — mostly in the West — rely strictly on cell phones. Those states were Colorado, Idaho, Kentucky, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Oregon and Texas.

At the other end, only six states — mostly in the East — joined New Jersey and Rhode Island in having fewer than 17 percent of adults using only cell phones. They were Connecticut, Delaware, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and South Dakota.

The CDC estimates were based largely on data from the agency’s National Health Interview Survey, for which it has interviewed 109,187 households over the past 3½ years.

The government also uses statistics from the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey taken between 2006 and 2009, plus information from listed telephone directories. The figures are then blended to produce a single estimate.

The report is available at http:///www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr039.pdf.

But even in Arkansas, some people are holding tight to their land lines.

“I was taught to have a house phone at home, whether you use it or not,” said Dale West, 40, who carries a $60-a-month cell phone and pays about $35 a month for his land line. “Even though you got a cell phone, you never know.”

Fram reported from Washington. Associated Press writers Emily Wagster Pettus in Jackson, Miss., and Bruce Shipkowski in Trenton, N.J., contributed to this report.


Have feedback? Want to know more? Send us ideas for follow-up stories.

You may also like