At Alfond Arena in Orono, Tyler McConnell scored twice and Sam Henderson racked up four assists to propel the Black Bears to victory.
Ben Allen-Rahill, Josh Wheeler, Tanner Evans and Trent Lick tallied a goal apiece for Old Town-Orono. Kohle Parker made 21 saves.
Thomas Patenaude scored the goal for Presque Isle, which received 28 saves from Andrea Daigle.