At Presque Isle, Tyler Seeley scored with 3:48 remaining in the game to lift the Wildcats over the Broncos.
Colin McKay had a goal and an assist for Presque Isle (7-6), while Adam Flynn had the other PI goal. Scott Rhynold, Alex Michaud and Seeley added assists.
Luther Vom Eigen posted a goal and an assist for Hampden (3-6), while Riley Eastman scored off a Cooper Antone assist.
Jillian Flynn faced 21 shots in goal for PI, and Hampden goalie Ryan Manning faced 32.