At Hampden, Ryley Gray notched the game-tying goal for Machias with 27:17 left in the game as the Bulldogs and Greenville played to a tie through two overtimes.
Alex McCurdy netted the first goal for Machias (4-8-2) with 15:59 left in the first half on a pass from Logan Wood. A.J. Dolley stopped 20 of 26 shots.
Matt DiAngelo and Tristan Richards each scored a goal for Greenville (8-4-2) late in the first half. Henry Hersey picked up two assists. Cory Henderson made 10 saves on 14 shots.