October 16, 2018
Midcoast Latest News | Poll Questions | Mary Mayhew | Susan Collins | Election 2018

Neighboring communities will vote on Maine town’s bid to limit school choice

Christine LaPado-Breglia | Lincoln County News
Christine LaPado-Breglia | Lincoln County News
RSU 12 Board of Directors Chair Jerry Nault (from left), Superintendent Howard Tuttle, and Administrative Assistant Leslie Burgess attend a board meeting at Chelsea Elementary School on Thursday, May 10.

The town of Alna’s petition to amend the Regional School Unit 12 reorganization plan to restrict K-8 school choice will go to voters in the district’s seven towns June 12.

The Sheepscot Valley Regional School Unit board of directors passed the amendment after its second reading during a meeting at Chelsea Elementary School on May 10.

The board voted 13-2 and the weighted vote was 8,860-1,126. Two board members were absent for the written vote.

[Maine town votes to limit K-8 school choice payments]

The vote came after four people, all residents of Alna, weighed in during the public comment period — three in favor of the proposed amendment and one, Ona Brazwell, against. Brazwell, whose 7-year-old twins attend the Juniper Hill School for Place-Based Education in Alna, spoke of a “lack of diligence and research in drafting the petition.”

“Why are we changing a policy that has worked in Alna for 20 years?” she asked. “Why such a rush? I urge you all to please take pause. I urge you to vote no tonight.”

Alna Third Selectman Doug Baston spoke in support of the amendment.

“We’re a little town. We have no commercial tax base. We have one store … Little Alna can’t afford this,” Baston said, referring to the town’s current policy of funding private K-8 schooling for Alna residents.

Amendment proponent Beth Whitney said the town’s students “will continue to have complete public school choice. High school students will continue to have private school choice.”

“Please respect Alna’s choice,” Whitney said. “Please vote yes on the second reading and send it on to the voters.”

[Maine town muzzles public comment at meetings after school choice conflict]

Prior to the May 10 meeting, Alna’s petition to amend the reorganization plan was reviewed by an ad hoc subcommittee of the RSU 12 board, which concluded that there is “no reason to believe the Alna petition would be harmful,” according to board member Christopher Johnson, of Somerville, who spoke on behalf of the subcommittee.

The district’s towns — Alna, Chelsea, Palermo, Somerville, Westport Island, Whitefield, and Windsor — will vote June 12. If the amendment passes, the change will apply to children who move to Alna after June 30.

Greg Im, a public-finance attorney at Drummond Woodsum in Portland, was tasked with helping develop the text for the June 12 ballot question.

There was some discussion about possible changes to the language of the ballot question, with Baston asking Im if there could be “the equivalent of the secretary of state’s summary” in the wording.

“I tried to capture that in the second sentence,” said Im.

The exact wording of the ballot question was nailed down at the end of the meeting, after an executive session to discuss personnel.

The question reads: “Do you favor amending the Reorganization Plan for Sheepscot Valley Regional School Unit by inserting the underlined language shown below? This amendment, approved in concept by voters of the town of Alna at a March 23, 2018 non-binding referendum, would limit grades K-8 school choice to public schools for certain Alna resident students.”

The underlined language states, in part, that the “school choice provision shall apply to students in grades K-8 residing in Alna with their parent(s) or guardian with legal custody but who were not residing in Alna as of June 30, 2018, and whose parent(s) or guardian with legal custody have not continually resided in Alna since June 30, 2018.”

These students will be able to attend an RSU 12 school or another public school, provided that “if the tuition payable to the choice school exceeds the Sheepscot Valley Regional School Unit tuition rate, the additional expense … shall be an additional local assessment to the responsible municipality. The municipality may then assess the parent(s) or guardian for the amount of tuition paid over the established tuition rate for the RSU, including the Insured Value Factor.”

Follow the Bangor Daily News on Facebook for the latest Maine news.

 


Have feedback? Want to know more? Send us ideas for follow-up stories.

You may also like