June 18, 2018
Midcoast Latest News | Poll Questions | Tiny House Surprise | Antiquing | Stephen King

Defendant in Boothbay robbery jailed again

Lincoln County News | BDN
Lincoln County News | BDN
Michael L. Brewer
By J.W. Oliver, Lincoln County News

BOOTHBAY, Maine — A defendant in a Boothbay robbery case will remain in jail until his trial, following his third arrest in six months for alcohol-related bail violations.

Michael L. Brewer, 58, pleaded guilty to two counts of violation of condition of release on Thursday in Lincoln County Superior Court in Wiscasset.

He was sentenced to 20 days in jail and a $40 fine.

Brewer still faces charges of Class A robbery and Class B burglary in connection with a March 17, 2013, home invasion on Barters Island in Boothbay. He has denied those charges.

After being released on bail on the felony charges, Brewer was rearrested on Jan. 20 and May 11 for bail violations and other charges. He pleaded guilty to those bail violations and to a charge of refusing to submit to arrest or detention, physical force related to the Jan. 20 incident.

Most recently, Brewer had been released from jail on June 26 with bail conditions that prohibited his possessing or using alcohol and required him to live at an address in Union.

Lincoln County Sheriff’s Deputies Ryan Chubbuck and Jared Mitkus arrested Brewer at Lake Pemaquid Campground in Damariscotta early on July 7, Assistant District Attorney Andrew Wright said Thursday. Brewer was intoxicated at the time of his arrest.

“He stated to the officers that he had been living there since he had been released from jail,” Wright said. “Mr. Brewer had no intention of following the conditions that were set.”

Brewer’s attorney, Thaddeus Day, asked the court to allow Brewer to post bail again. Shortly after his release on June 26, Brewer and his girlfriend got engaged, then married, Day said.

“Mr. Brewer admittedly has an issue with alcohol and he knew it was against his conditions, but he was excited about getting married and he drank alcohol,” Day said.

Superior Court Justice Daniel Billings said Brewer’s excuse concerning an earlier bail violation was that a friend had recently died.

“So he drinks if things are going well and he drinks if things are not going well,” Billings said.

Day argued for Brewer’s release with strict conditions that he report to the Boothbay Harbor Police Department every day and live with a Boothbay resident who would provide additional supervision.

“I think that those very stringent requirements would be easily measurable and create all the safety the community would need in policing him on bail,” Day said.

Billings declined Day’s proposal. Brewer “was given opportunities twice before and continues to not comply with his bail conditions,” Billings said. “His bail will be revoked.”

The robbery case could go to trial in October.

Last month, Wright said Brewer “is typically referred to as the person with the longest criminal record in Lincoln County.” Brewer’s record includes a 1988 conviction for attempting to commit murder, along with numerous convictions for lesser crimes.

Wright has said the state will ask for the maximum sentence or something close if it obtains a conviction at trial. A Class A crime carries a maximum penalty of 30 years in prison and a $50,000 fine.


Have feedback? Want to know more? Send us ideas for follow-up stories.

You may also like