June 25, 2018
Aroostook Latest News | Poll Questions | John Williams | Red Meat Allergy | Bond Sale

Sentencing date set for Mars Hill man in kidnapping, murder plot case

Submitted photo | BDN
Submitted photo | BDN
Mark Stetson
By Jen Lynds, BDN Staff

MARS HILL, Maine — A sentencing date has been set for a local man found guilty in January for trying to hire someone to carry out a robbery, kidnapping and murder plot.

Mark S. Stetson, 43, will be sentenced on April 3 in Aroostook County Superior Court in Houlton, a court clerk confirmed Friday.

Aroostook County Assistant District Attorney Kurt Kafferlin said earlier this week that Stetson’s sentencing is the only case that will be heard in court that day.

Stetson, 43, pleaded guilty in Aroostook County Superior Court in Caribou on Jan. 14 to solicitation of murder, solicitation of kidnapping and solicitation of robbery. A jury had been selected for a trial that was to begin the next day, but Stetson changed his mind and instead entered guilty pleas. He appeared with his attorney, Luke Rossignol of Presque Isle.

Stetson was first arrested in March 2009 and charged with domestic violence terrorizing for alleged threats made against a woman. The Bangor Daily News is not naming the woman because she is considered a victim.

Later that same month, Stetson was charged with violation of condition of release for having prohibited contact with the woman, according to District Attorney Todd Collins.

Collins said Stetson was also charged in a number of other incidents involving the woman in 2010 and 2011. He was in and out of jail after being convicted on multiple charges including domestic violence stalking, violation of a protective order and violation of condition of release.

At one point, while being transported by Maine State Police, Stetson made multiple threats to kill the woman. The statements were recorded on the trooper’s in-car camera, according to Collins. Following the alleged threats, Stetson was held without bail.

In late January 2011, while Stetson was being held without bail, another inmate at the jail approached jail staff and reported that Stetson had offered to pay him if he would kill the woman.

Lt. Larry Goff of the Aroostook County Sheriff’s Department began investigating the informant’s allegations.

Collins said Goff discovered that the informant, who was being held on charges out of Penobscot County and was previously unfamiliar with Stetson, had detailed information regarding the woman. The inmate also showed Goff directions and notes along with a rough drawing of the interior of the woman’s residence, which he indicated was drawn by Stetson.

Collins said Goff then coordinated his efforts with other members of his own department as well as members of the State Police, the Maine Drug Enforcement Agency and the District Attorney’s Office.

The inmate informant agreed to wear a recording device and initiate another conversation with Stetson, Collins said. The inmate told Stetson that he was getting out on bail and needed the information again. While being recorded, Stetson once again gave detailed information as to the woman’s location and schedule. The two discussed details about how the individual would break into the woman’s home, shoot her twice to make sure she was dead, steal items from the home and tie up a minor child, according to the district attorney.

Collins said that Stetson wanted assurances that they would keep the information between them and allegedly told the other inmate, “If they bug this place I’m gonna go to jail forever.”

Stetson then was arrested on the solicitation of robbery, kidnapping and murder charges in April 2011.

Collins said that this was the sixth in a series of cases involving Stetson. Prior to this case being set for trial, Stetson was convicted and sentenced in all five previous cases.

Stetson is currently incarcerated at the Maine State Prison. He was not offered a plea deal in this case.

The most serious offense, criminal solicitation of murder, is a Class A crime and carries a maximum sentence of 30 years in prison. The other offenses, criminal solicitation of kidnapping and robbery, are Class B crimes and carry maximum sentences of 10 years of confinement.

Have feedback? Want to know more? Send us ideas for follow-up stories.

You may also like