Environmental group says LePage ‘green’ order promotes destructive logging

Posted Dec. 14, 2011, at 7:05 a.m.
Last modified Dec. 14, 2011, at 8:22 a.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     
Gov. Paul LePage
Gov. Paul LePage

AUGUSTA, Maine — A national environmental group says Gov. Paul LePage’s recent executive order expanding the standards for “green” timber required for state construction projects would lead to unsustainable wood harvesting.

Last week, the governor announced the broader standards for timber used in new or expanded state building construction. The administration said the order would bolster the state’s forest products industry and protect jobs.

But the Natural Resources Defense Council says the mandate is “greenwashing” — deceptively championing a policy as environmentally friendly — because its definition of “green” is so broad it no longer requires sustainable wood harvesting, effectively exempting state projects from having to use wood certified by the Forest Stewardship Council. The FSC certification, administered through the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design program, requires wood to be harvested in a sustainable manner.

In a recent news release, the Defense Council said the governor’s order would lead to destructive logging. Sami Yassa, a senior scientist with the group, called the change “government-sponsored greenwashing.”

“Eliminating LEED effectively turns Maine’s once-great green building program into business as usual,” Yassa said in a prepared statement. “The governor has chosen to benefit a small segment of the state’s logging industry, often financed by out-of-state interests, who refuse to improve their practices.”

Yassa said more than 60 organizations in Maine are members of the U.S. Green Building Council, which represents the state’s green building industry. The industry, Yassa said, employs more than 60,000 people.

Yassa said exempting state projects from the FSC certification threatens more than $5 billion in economic activity by the state’s green building industry.

“By moving the state’s emerging green-building economy backwards, LePage is attacking one of the bright spots in the economy right now,” Yassa said. “His support of unsustainable forestry defies the interests of his citizens and common sense.”

The administration, however, said the move would allow the state’s forest products industry to be more competitive by getting “green” certification from other programs.

“By requiring state building projects to use ‘green’ materials under more certification programs, we are increasing the amount of Maine-produced wood available for public construction projects,” LePage said in a statement.

Bill Beardsley, commissioner of the Department of Conservation, said the order demonstrated the state’s broadening commitment to “voluntary forest certification.”

“It will create an even playing field among the diverse forest certification groups, both nationally and internationally,” Beardsley said in a news release. “It means that the local community college will be able to build using the certified wood products from the local sawmill.”

According to the administration, the state’s forest products industry directly and indirectly supports 55,000 jobs, annually generates more than $3 billion in earnings and contributes $4.3 billion annually to Maine’s gross domestic product. Maine also has the nation’s highest percentage of certified, private forestland.

Certification standards set the benchmarks for landowners to meet environmental and ecological harvesting goals. By expanding the state’s certification program to include “green building,” the administration says it’s supporting the competitiveness of the forest industry.

To see more from the Sun Journal visit sunjournal.com

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SHNOU64ZBOBIKWUF5IM6WSH7WA entitled4life

    It’s no surprise that the Natural Resources Defense Council is opposed to this, it’s what they do.   The group is not interested in helping Maine business, just in making sure that they protect the natural resources, whatever the cost and whatever the detriment and no matter if it can be done more cheaply and more fairly for the businesses involved.

  • Anonymous

    It just doesnt matter to you guys what this man does…This Bias paper is always against what ever he does..We need jobs here.. This is a start in the right direction .. Why is it the Canadians can harvest timber  here cheaper than us..Answer regulations..He has a next to impossible job ahead of unstrapping all the red tape that your democrats buddys strapped on this state…Your time will come when sombody starts a balanced newpaper up here and that will happen

  • Anonymous

    “Eliminating LEED effectively turns Maine’s once-great green building program into business as usual,” Yassa said in a prepared statement. “The governor has chosen to benefit a small segment of the state’s logging industry, often financed by out-of-state interests, who refuse to improve their practices.”Yassa said more than 60 organizations in Maine are members of the U.S. Green Building Council, which represents the state’s green building industry. The industry, Yassa said, employs more than 60,000 people.
    Yassa said exempting state projects from the FSC certification threatens more than $5 billion in economic activity by the state’s green building industry”

    ? did either of you read the story? looks like the governor will hurt mare than he helps

    Bill Beardsley, commissioner of the Department of Conservation, said the order demonstrated the state’s broadening commitment to “voluntary forest certification
    yeah and we all know what “voluntary” means to business

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7T3YNF6MG3FPEAVTFIJC44VQUI Dlbrt

    The Only thing GREEN  about Lepage is his Teeth!

  • Anonymous

    Is anybody surprised that the Republican agenda is absolutely about creating jobs right now, even if it means leaving a trashed and ugly America for the future. 

    However, only certain jobs that favor the interest of big business–

    Case in point:  Right now, Republicans in Congress are refusing to extend tax breaks for the middle class unless Democrats allow an oil pipeline down through America from Canada.  The pipeline goes right through the sensitive Sandhills region.

  • Guest

    STOP WHINNING… Poor Penguin!

  • Anonymous

    If we continue to tighten regulations and laws geared towards limiting industry then we will soon wake up jobless and homeless in the “green” utopia touted by the environmentalists.

    It is the cost of doing business!
    there will always be consequences of doing business, especially when it is natural resources.
    however, it’s either we encourage business and let it happen, or we continue to tighten policies and no business will come to the state.

  • Anonymous

    The Maine logging industry is suffering right now from lack of orders. The governor’s approach is only intended to shore up the industry at a time when it really needs a boost. What creates environmental abuse due to logging is the feast or famine approach we are now seeing. When demand is high there is an emphasis on harvesting as quickly as possible to make up for those periods of low demands. This only encourages a lot of wood harvesting malpractices and environmental degradation.

  • Anonymous

    “sustainable forestry practices” ensure that the forestry businesses will be viable in the future, and is not necessarily a cost burden to the company. LEED standards are tough, but Maine organizations are meeting them in new construction projects and are still purchasing their products from Maine companies – which is part of the LEED standards to reduce carbon footprint through reducing transportation distances.

  • http://twitter.com/MarshallLeslie Marshall Leslie

    Both the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), and your paper’s article, fail to disclose that the NRDC led the official initiative that created and funded the Forest Stewardship Council in the US more than a decade ago, and the NRDC has a very large conflict-of-interest on this issue. As well, the NRDC release, and your paper’s article, fail to disclose that the NRDC’s (then) Chief Scientist was the principle author of the LEED rating system (which by the way is based on a Canadian standard). The NRDC and LEED borrowed the idea of having a ‘credit’ for sustainable forest management from the Canadian standards system.

    Governor LePage’s order simply introduces an element of choice when specifying wood products – which LEED in fact already permits. Under LEED’s point system, SFI and PEFC certified wood can earn a ‘credit’ if they are produced and transported within a short radius of the building site – which one assumes is the policy objective of the Governor of Maine. (LEED will soon permit an even broader use of wood certified by different systems).

    What you should be sharing with your readers is this: most wood products aren’t certified by ANYONE, and most LEED certified building projects don’t earn ANY certified wood credit. So kudos to Governor LePage for increasing the opportunity for sustainable harvested wood products in Maine, and I hope other elected officials sit up and take notice.

  • Anonymous

    If anyone doesn’t like what is going on in this state,then I have 1 word for you-MOVE!

  • Briney

    Yassa said. “His (Le Page) support of unsustainable forestry defies the interests of his citizens and common sense.”
    Defies the interests of his citizens and common sense?  That about wraps up everything Le Page has done and said in his first year as Monarch of the State of Maine.

  • Anonymous

    Another corporate friendly policy that does harm to real Mainers and how they make a living.  When will people see that this “business friendly” front from LePage is a rouse.  He is friendly to big, out-of-state corporations and damning local businesses and workers to a sad future.

    I can see why Charles and David Koch would want this policy.  I can also see why Mainers might be concerned.  Unsustainable harvesting is bad for the next generation but good for this quarter’s financials. 

    I’m sure ALEC has policies for this kind of forestry mismanagement but it surely isn’t of Mainers, by Mainers and for Mainers.

  • Anonymous

    I read your posts often.  I am sure if the NRDC said that eating arsenic is bad for you, you would make the argument that arsenic is good for you.  Unsustainable forestry is not in the best interests of Mainers, period.  You can make the case for out-of-state businesses but not for us.  There are too many ways we rely on the forests for our way of life.

  • Briney

    Maine has had 23 Democratic governors and 37 Republican governors.  There have been 2 Independent and 6 Democratic- Republican governors. Also, 4 Whig governors. 

    For anyone with time on their hands, they could review and unravel the red tape,  and find out what governor and what administration was responsible for weaving the most. 

    But it is interesting to note that since Republican Gov. John Reed finished an 8-yr term in 1967, he was succeeded  by two Independents, 2 Republicans and, just one Democrat, Gov. John Baldacci.  

    Since Governor Reed began his term in 1959, this means that 52 years have passed with just one Democrat – Governor John Baldacci  serving from 2003 to 2011. 

    The article presents both sides of the issue.

  • Anonymous

    so… any suggestions?
    how are we supposed to have any business in this state?

    The service sector?
    fast food?
    banking?

    Not Sustainable!

    there needs to be some business here that is productive. and every single opportunity to have a productive business is generally shot down by the environmentalists as “bad for mainers”

    fishing, forestry, manufacturing, wind power, rail transportation…
    everyone has to have a say in it, and discourage it.
    at this rate, Maine will be a nice green wilderness filled with absolutely no one because no one will be able to find work or live here!

  • Anonymous

    Curtis and Brennan?  Longley, much like Cutler, was a Democrat until it became apparent that he’d be unable to win a primary.  King’s start in Maine politics was working for Democratic politicians as well.

  • PabMainer

    The greatest disservice to our woodlands is not to reasonably and sensibly harvest our most abundant natural resource….Softwood harvesting is down approx. 25% over the last decade…..the rate of maturing trees becoming harvestable comes approx. every 20 years supplying new marketable wood…..this rate of growth is increasing and is projected to increase yearly thru 2030…..Our woods are a mess and one needs to just drive some mature wood lots to see that undergrowth and non-harvested mature wood is overtaking itself….Appropriate wood management involves adequate harvesting balanced by appropriate growth and re-growth…..no one wants to see our woodlands abused, but not using them to their potential is wasteful and not good land management…..people want jobs, and hopefully this effort will increase jobs and business while protecting any misuse of the natural resource itself..

  • Anonymous

    “AUGUSTA, Maine — A national environmental group says Gov. Paul LePage’s recent executive order expanding the standards for “green” timber required for state construction projects would lead to unsustainable wood harvesting.” 

    This knocks the props out from under the anti-National Park people claims to being such great managers of our sustainable resources.

  • Anonymous

    “It’s no surprise that the Natural Resources Defense Council is opposed to this, it’s what they do.   The group is not interested in helping Maine business …”  

    Who are you going to believe ? 
    The Heritage Foundation’s front man ? 

    Meanwhile , is there any new business to be discussed, yet, Govenah ? 

  • Anonymous

    “there will always be consequences of doing business, especially when it is natural resources.
    however, it’s either we encourage business and let it happen, or we continue to tighten policies and no business will come to the state.” 

    So why don’t business people accept those costs ? Opening a course for blackjack dealers at a State school is a current good example of them getting the State to pay their training costs. Why isn’t  that corporate welfare ?  

    Now that the GOTea Party has a record, the broad general statements, all the bromides,  
    don’t fly anymore. 

    Get real, conservatives.

  • Anonymous

    Do you support corporate welfare, Mr. Monk ? 

  • Anonymous

    Yours is a false choice. There is no need to damage the environment to create jobs. This is a ploy to get corporate resource hogs higher profits. It does nothing for Maine or Maine people. Show me how using sustainable forestry is going to hurt any aspect of our economy….I challenge you!

  • Anonymous

    Voici une autre raison pourquoi l’un ne devrait pas avoir confiance dans cet grenouille-la. I still want to see his birth certificate.

  • Anonymous

    Just another example of what an idiot our governor is

  • Anonymous

    Oh, the poor Koch brothers. If only oppressive regulations weren’t keeping them down. Why have we punished these men for their success? They are only worth $25 billion! How are they supposed to create jobs?

  • Anonymous

    Like you, I believe it is more important to play the blame game than to fix something.

  • Anonymous

    The Natural Resources Defense Council objects to cabins in the woods.

    The more headlines I see like this, the more respect I have for LePage

  • Anonymous

    I’m confused by the masses thinking the government is suppose to make jobs for people.
    First Thers New Qorld Order people were jumping for joy about bot even knowing
    it’s what Hilter was trying to do. Ask Europe
    how’s it’s working out for them.
    Next, why do people think the government is
    going to create jobs when they helped them leave?
    Lastly every time someone whines about little
    stupid things and incites the government in it
    creates more problems and cost more tax dollars.
    So I ask why do people expect the government to
    help and why would they even ask crooks for help,
    Thank you for an intelligent response.

  • Anonymous

    who’s

  • Anonymous

    not even close

  • Anonymous

    OK Maine we say you cannot log no more…..the national environmental groups only criticize, they should come up with solutions… if they could think.

  • Anonymous

    amen

  • Anonymous

    Cut it all…. Let God sort and stack it.

  • Anonymous

    The dems have held a death grip on the Senate and house for over 30 years as well…OOOh those pesky facts again…LOL…

  • Anonymous

    That settles it …. 

    Me Forest (Gump ?) has spoken. 

  • Anonymous

    Whose ( I think you mean) , Forrest.

    Credible is as credible does.

  • Anonymous

    EARTH FIRST…WE”LL LOG THE OTHER PLANETS LATER…LOL..

    LePage is doing what’s right…How can I tell you say ??? The BDN and the usual suspects have their collective panties in a bunch…LOL…

  • Anonymous

    Me whinning……Look who whinning every time Paul. makes a decisons that effects you run are down in augusta and protest …Since 75% of you dont work you can occupy down there months at a time,crying “why us” “I dont want to work”I know every time Iam on here I have 90% of the Bangor daily News blogging on here in defence of this BIAS paper..People are getting real sick of reading this   negitive Left leaning paper.. Keep on reporting unbalance crap..There will be a fair reporting newspaper that will be comming out…I promise you that.. 

  • Anonymous

    who’s birth certificate

  • Anonymous

    SINCE HE GOT IN THERE MORE GREEN IN MY WALLET!

  • Anonymous

    LePage, who else? I’m not convinced he’s a U.S. citizen. Why do you think he printed all of those campaign stickers in French? That and he has been less than forthcoming about his early life with his birth parents and that English is his second language. I wouldn’t be surprised at all to find out he was born on the wrong side of the St. John River, if you know what I mean.

  • Anonymous

    He could even be an illegal alien.

  • Anonymous

    What else would one expect from laplague and his gang in Augusta but more of the same. Nothing good for the people of Maine, helps profits at a few big outfits though.

  • Anonymous

    those “jobs” you speak of: mostly canadian drivers/loggers.

  • Anonymous

    Your “death grip” reference to dems control of the Maine Senate and House was accomplished through free elections or will of the people.

  • Anonymous

    huh?

  • Anonymous

    wow, and I can’t build a deck on my camp because it’s too close to the water at 94 feet.  

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7T3YNF6MG3FPEAVTFIJC44VQUI Dlbrt

    $ 134.00 average Maine family Tax Savings!

    Great, buy yourself a cardboard box to live in with the change!

    Your a gonna need it!

  • Anonymous

    They speak French in Lebanon, don’t they ? 

    I want DHS to see his birth certificate. 

  • Anonymous

    Just like the Sahara and Great Gobi Forrests ?

  • Anonymous

    Ouch! lol. Ease up with the pertinent facts, you will make some people cry.

  • Anonymous

    this bais paper even puts are comments down at the bottom now…They dont like what we have to say…there time will come

  • Anonymous

    Poor Paul’s stock just went up in Quebec. Does anyone, even his supporters, believe he is talking about logging jobs for Mainers?

  • Anonymous

    So I’m just checking. 

    The short answer to the right wing propaganda about everything being the faults of 
    30 years of Democratic rule, is to dare them to show thirty years of Democratic Governors since Gov. Reed … who was first appointed Governor in 1959, right ?  

    How should we put that ? 

    Name two Democrat who were Gov. of the State of Maine since 1959 ?   

    Any other suggestions ? 

  • Anonymous

    Okay, thank you.
    Now , we are getting somewhere on this lie. So at 8 years each, given they seemed to re-elected, I notice, that is still only 24 years, and only 15 years rre since 1980… the past thirty yrs, right ? Cool, the wing nuts are only bout half wrong…. that is way better than their usual average, and there is room to compromise with them, now. 

  • Anonymous

    I’d like to that “death grip” documented, too. 

  • Anonymous

    I don’t think that the beautiful Maine environment should be taken for granted. I for one am currently training as a professional out of state and intend to return to Maine to open my business, and doing so will create more jobs. However, I will only bring my business to the state if it stays as beautiful and outdoorsman-friendly as it is now. Why else would I return to Maine as a young, highly educated professional, when clearly opportunities are bigger and better elsewhere? Would I return for the high number of affluent consumers available to bring revenue to my business, or for the swinging city life, or maybe for the high number of professional positions available (please note heavy sarcasm)? Please, Maine’s environment is the only thing it has that is worthwhile. If Maine’s environment degraded then I would swiftly pack up for another state and take my business with me, because I can assure you that I would make far more money elsewhere in the career I intend to enter into.

  • Anonymous

    Natural Resource Defense Council is an enemy of Northern Maine they are a job killing organization, Governor Lepage is moving Maine in the right direction, after years of Democrats and Environmentalist controlling our state we now have hope for a brighter future for our children, Thank You Governor.

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business