Is this website offering the future of education?

Posted Aug. 07, 2011, at 6:17 a.m.
Last modified Aug. 07, 2011, at 9:20 a.m.
Print this   E-mail this    Facebook this   Tweet this     
Salman Kahn is offering instruction through videos on his website at Kahn Academy.
.
Salman Kahn is offering instruction through videos on his website at Kahn Academy.

Here’s how Salman Khan thinks schools should work: Students should learn lessons online and do homework and projects in class.

This “flipping” of the traditional classroom is the operating system espoused by Khan and his Khan Academy, a website whose popularity is exploding as millions tune into its free videos, practice exercises and assessment tools.

Khan’s videos provide basic tutorials, mostly in math and science, that students can watch repeatedly in class or at home and pause if they need to — something that can’t happen with a classroom lecture. Teachers are then free to work individually with students and be more creative.

And that, Khan says, enables class time to be “an optimal experience for students and teachers.”

Recently hailed as revolutionary by Bill Gates, Google and some in the media, the concept is gaining traction among educators. Teachers view the site as a useful tool to individualize learning, says Dennis Van Roekel, who taught for 23 years and now is president of the National Education Association.

“Our members see it as something that really does help students,” he said. “Everybody doesn’t learn at the same pace. But once you’ve got it, you’ve got it.”

Karen Cator, director of the Department of Education’s Office of Educational Technology, says Khan automated “something that is so recognizable in our view of education: I have to solve problems, and somebody has to tell me how to do that. . . . It has caught on like wildfire.”

Since Khan first posted math videos on YouTube to tutor his cousins in 2004, the former hedge fund analyst has expanded his video library to 2,400 lessons that include basic addition, advanced calculus, history and science. Users also can access exercises and track their progress.

Based in California’s Silicon Valley, the Khan Academy was established as a nonprofit organization in 2008. Its lessons have been viewed by more than 60 million users, the website says, and are being translated into 10 languages. Khan estimates the website is being used in more than 1,000 classrooms nationwide, including in a pilot math program in two fifth- and seventh-grade classes in Los Altos, Calif., public schools last year. The district plans to expand the pilot program to all fifth- and sixth-grade classes this fall.

Khan, who quit his job in finance in 2009 to serve as the academy’s executive director, views the academy as a stand-alone virtual classroom. “That’s what our mission is: a world-class education for everyone that’s free,” he said.

There’s no doubt that the Khan Academy’s videos, narrated enthusiastically by Khan himself, have struck a chord among students and educators as well as the independent learners who make up the majority of the site’s visitors. Users only hear Khan’s voice; he never appears on screen, and he uses neon colors to write on a computer blackboard.

Microsoft founder Bill Gates is a fan; the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation made a $1.5 million donation to the academy in 2010. In a video posted on the academy website, Gates says he sees Khan as a pioneer in the movement to use technology to educate people. “It’s the start of a revolution,” Gates says. Google awarded the academy $2 million that year for winning a crowd-sourced contest offering money to organizations with world-changing ideas.

The Khan Academy joins a crowded field of free and for-profit online learning programs, which some tout as the future of education and as options for cash-strapped school districts looking to cut staff.

But educators caution that what Khan offers is just another tool — albeit an effective one — that teachers can use to engage students. The Khan Academy and other online learning sites are no substitute for classroom teachers, they say.

“Technology is not going to replace teachers, but it empowers them to be much more effective with students,” Cator said. “There is an unbelievable opportunity that we have to leverage how people learn through technology.”

Khan acknowledges that his website is not a new idea. “We’re not the first people to put video online,” he said. “What’s different is we started off as a grass-roots, bottom-up thing, reaching students before we started going into the classroom.”

Students in Montgomery County, Md., can tune in to the Math Dude, a series of online math videos by former math teacher Mike DeGraba designed to help middle- and high-school students improve algebra skills. And Stacey Roshan, a math teacher at Bullis School in Potomac, Md., created what she calls a “backwards classroom” by videotaping and posting online her lessons for her Advanced Placement calculus class. She requires students to watch them at home and uses class time to work on homework problems.

“It forces you to try to figure out as much as you can on your own. We’re taking ownership of our learning,” Bullis student Daniel Gray, who graduated in June, said of Roshan’s teaching strategy.

But that’s one of the problems with online learning, educators say. Even sites as sophisticated as the Khan Academy can’t be relied upon to expose everything a student hasn’t learned.

Good teachers listen to students and understand their prior experience to discover where they lack understanding, says Heidi Glidden, assistant director in the education issues department of the American Federation of Teachers.

“To suggest that all kids are able to learn using only one medium wasn’t realistic years ago, and we don’t function that way today,” Glidden said.

Even though the students can earn “badges” as they master Khan Academy exercises, a computer program is no substitute for the motivation that teachers provide, educators say. “A teacher motivates youngsters to aspire to go beyond where they’d go if left alone to their own devices,” said Daniel Domenech, executive director of the American Association of School Administrators.

Still, educators are embracing the technology because it opens doors to new resources and learning techniques. Whereas teachers and students used to rely on books for information, they can now access an infinite world of information with the click of a mouse.

But that world requires vetting. As the Khan Academy ventures beyond basic math and science lessons, and deeper into subjective material such as U.S. history, users will need to navigate lessons with a more critical eye, educators say.

The need to monitor online learning is one example of how technology is changing the teacher’s role. No longer mainly lecturers, teachers are becoming directors of learning who guide students, educators say. “The teacher is not the only one imparting knowledge. The teacher becomes much more of a facilitator of learning,” the NEA’s Van Roekel said.

Khan says he’s had to deal with the misconceptions that using the Khan Academy reduces the need for teachers or that class sizes can increase. Instead, he believes that using the website adds value to the role of a teacher, who becomes a mentor or coach.

“A mentor is much higher up the value chain than a lecturer,” he said. “Someone who designs projects and experiments is higher up the value chain.”

The concept of flipping the classroom is key to the mentoring role: If students are learning the basics through watching videos, then teachers can spend class time on more creative projects instead of practice drills and homework assignments.

Students can work problems at their own pace until they get them right, while the assessment tool tracks progress for teachers, identifying when students need help and how long it takes them to grasp a concept.

“Every teacher will tell you, ‘I wish I had more time with students,’ ” Khan says.

Similar articles:

Marketplace News

Marketplace

Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

The Bangor Daily News encourages comments about stories, but you must follow our terms of service.

In brief:

  1. Keep it civil and stay on topic
  2. No vulgarity, racial slurs, name-calling or personal attacks.
  3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. Here are some guidelines (see more):

  • Anonymous

    Great article, BDN.

  • 525_44

    Full impulse power!
    Just kidding, it’s not bad, check it out.

  • Anonymous

    I discovered Khan Academy about a year ago.  Now both my sons age 11 and 15  use it all the time.  On their own! They think it is great!  Me Too!

  • Anonymous

    Just like the telephone landline business, education is going to change rapidly in this country and traditional  teaching teachers are afraid.  Using it already and the kids love it.

  • Anonymous

    Just like the telephone landline business, education is going to change rapidly in this country and traditional  teaching teachers are afraid.  Using it already and the kids love it.

  • Anonymous

    Just like the telephone landline business, education is going to change rapidly in this country and traditional  teaching teachers are afraid.  Using it already and the kids love it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/antonio.giarratano Antonio Giarratano

    And they wonder why kids in America are getting dumber and dumber. Let’s use technology for everything. What ever happened to kids going to school, working on work and lectures, then going home and their parents helping them with their homework? Why bother, someone else can do it now. It’s amazing how at one time we led this world in education. We put men on the moon. We cracked the atom. Now all it seems we do is find more and more ways fro our fat, lazy children to sit at a computer and vegetate while the parents are busy doing others stuff, like work and getting drunk. No wonder there are so many dropouts, so many unemployed, because all people do is find the easy way out of life and let a computer run their lives.

  • Anonymous

    Man, you sound depressed and hopeless. Apparently you hang around different young people than I do. I see some incredible young people working hard and going off to college. We have the highest number of college graduates in the history of this country. I am extremely proud of my children and all of their friends because they are doing incredible things. 

    Our educational system is not working and it is not because of technology. It is because we are not using technology to its fullest potential. 

  • Anonymous

    The best way to cope with change is to help create it. Hopefully educators and parents will research and try these new things and will incorporate what works for their kids, knowing that all kids are different and that they have different learning styles.  I love being able to do some things online, but I need people and love interacting with other people and sharing ideas, so I think this mix would work well for me. Being able to rewind and listen again to concepts that are tough for me but that other people get immediately, not having to listen to something I already know when I want to move on, getting up and move around when I reach the point of saturation…How can these things be negative? Interacting with people to emphasize what has been learned and to remind ourselves that we cannot function on technology alone is still necessary. It’s all about balance.

  • Anonymous

    This method is simply asking students to come to school
    prepared so the teacher can assist them and build on their existing knowledge. Not a revolutionary concept but what the technology does is allow
    the instructional materials to be at the demand and pace of the student (and
    parent). Motivation to learn still must be present and these video lessons are a
    medium of delivery that does inspire many students. Saying that technology
    makes children fat and lazy is like saying food makes people fat and
    lazy  – it is not the simple fact
    that an item is consumed – whether it is knowledge or substance – what matters is the quantity and the value – your flawed logic suggests that technology only offers twinkies to children.

  • Anonymous

    This looks great, but thank God the liberal spin of the BDN is “not” an educational tool for our schools.

     

    .

  • Anonymous

    There are so many awesome educators out there, and I bet many of them have your outlook. What a tool this must be for them! As in any occupation, there are some who will go kicking and screaming. Maybe they will turn to a field  that is more suitable for them. One can only hope. If you want to teach kids successfully, I think you cannot be lazy or complacent when it comes to the methods you use. I am always amazed, and saddened, when I hear of teachers who are using the same lesson plans today that they used 2, 5, or 10 years ago. Never underestimate the value and effect of a teacher who keeps trying to be valuable and effective.

  • Anonymous

    Our children are instilled with the digital culture as early as 18 months (Baby Einstein).  For some, by the time they are 9 – 10 they a cell phone.  In high school, a smart phone.  Laptop computers, video games, prepaid Visa cards, their worlds moves as fast an adults - if not faster. 

    Having them sit and listen to a person talk about a subject for an hour, geared toward the third or second slowest student can be agonizing.  Teachers can act as official bottlenecks  between the wealth of information outside the classroom and a child’s curiosity, willingness, and drive learn. 

    If I was the Education Commissioner in an effort to raise test scores and lower high school dropout rates, incorporating the Khan Academy into the K-12 cirriculum would be priority number 1. 

  • Anonymous

    If my kids do not understand something in their math or science classes, they go to Khan. It is like having their own tutor at their beck and call. It is an awesome site, and it is FREE!
    Hopefully students who are about to drop out will use Khan to stay involved in their studies and not fall prey to discouragement.
    The kids that use Khan are not fat and lazy. They are educated and motivated and more prepared to compete with other well educated  students than they otherwise would be.
     Khan Academy is the best thing that has happened in education, ever.
     

  • Anonymous

    This is how many of the classes at UMaine already work. It makes a lot of sense because the professors are there to help you through the work. The only problem with using it in high school is that you have to trust younger kids to do the lessons at home, and I could see this being a problem.

  • Anonymous

    This is how many of the classes at UMaine already work. It makes a lot of sense because the professors are there to help you through the work. The only problem with using it in high school is that you have to trust younger kids to do the lessons at home, and I could see this being a problem.

  • Anonymous

    This is how many of the classes at UMaine already work. It makes a lot of sense because the professors are there to help you through the work. The only problem with using it in high school is that you have to trust younger kids to do the lessons at home, and I could see this being a problem.

  • Anonymous

    This is how many of the classes at UMaine already work. It makes a lot of sense because the professors are there to help you through the work. The only problem with using it in high school is that you have to trust younger kids to do the lessons at home, and I could see this being a problem.

  • Anonymous

    So dose that go for all stores to dose that mean the cashier uses a pen an paper to add up all the things to brough to the cash register  ?? Theses days if you don’t have computer skills you will not get a job every company uses computers is one way or another

  • Anonymous

    I am a math teacher and I love this site. I use it quite often in class. I also encourage my students to go to it as a resource if they are having a problem with a homework assignment. We are trying to teach problem solving and this is another tool for them to use.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DL4QM53ISG3TTKFDFNQU6L7ZLE Cary

    As a teacher, I fully embrace the concept of what the Khan academy offers.  To me, the greatest aspect of this system is to finally allow me as an educator to provide one on one instruction across the vast spectrum of abilities of my students.  The current (and aged) model of providing instruction to upwards of 28 students in a 46 minute classroom setting is simply outdated.

  • Anonymous

    If you check your history a little bit, I bet that you would find that we were able to go to the moon, crack the atom, and send satellites into orbit because of the German and Austrian educational system. Granted, people like VonBraun and Einstein  worked here in the United States, but they could have very well ended up working for the Russians had history been a bit different. In the case of Einstein, what if he had not emigrated to America prior to WWII?

  • Purav Patel

    Antonio Giarratano 

    We did NOT lead the world in education “at one time”. According to international testing and tertiary graduation rates from the 1940s-1970s, even in the so-called ‘good-old-days”, America was very much average in education. In facts, just decades ago, high school and college graduation rates were much much lower. Since the 1950s, and more recently, the increase in AP courses taken (and passed) in high school seem to indicate (contrary to your argument) that education is in fact improving in the US. Also, the point you make about computers dumbing down education is unwarranted insofar as it’s plain wrong. According to Khan’s preliminary data from his pilot programs, pass rates in classes have improved. In short, your argument (or what tries hard to pass as one) is shallow and unfounded. 

  • Anonymous

    I have downloaded tons of podcasts from Khan and I love em. This is just another tool to be used in the classroom and at home. In school I was one of the lazy students. As they used to tell my parents. “if only he would apply himself.” Outside of school however, I devoured all the knowledge I could from as many sources as I could find. It would have been great to have this tool 30 years ago. Again, this is just a tool. The pen and paper are also just tools.
    Like bradford, I discovered the Khan Academy last year while looking for educational downloads for myself. Learning new information and skills should be a lifelong goal, not just for students. If the desire to learn is fostered in the present and future student populations, this, and other websites can only help our society.

  • Anonymous

    Might I suggest sending a couple of medium range probes to check out the site first. Guarantee that when the telemetry is sent back, many people will head straight in at WF 9. KA is a fantastic place to learn. And I can learn while sitting on my porch sipping my morning coffee.

  • Anonymous

    And Washington Post.  Thanks, BDN for including it.

  • Anonymous

    Works for many kids with a decent and supportive home life, but doesn’t alwys even then.  As for the kids who don’t have decent home support (or even not much of a home), this could be a way out for many.  As others have said, it’s the blend of methods and resources that has a better chance of working.
    We should have no problem with advances in technology supporting education, not supplanting it.

  • Anonymous

    Wow, you also Can’tAvoidPoiticizing, can you.  Actually, students should read more newpapers and news sources, a variety of course to get all viewpoints (and spins).

  • Anonymous

    Used as a supplement to classrom activites and reading the textbook, sounds like a good process.  It would allow more time for interactive contact between teachers and students, including the teachers regularly asking students, “What do you think?”.  However, teachers should read the posted material ahead of time to check on content and delivery.  For example, I’d be leery of Texas-style history or several misinterpratations of scientific topics.

  • 525_44

    It’s what is done with the computer that makes it a useful tool.
    Unfortunately too many children have been allowed to continually use it as a toy.

    If a child is allowed to sit and vegetate at the computer it’s up to the parent to intervene and separate the child from the computer.

    The computer itself does not ruin lives, farmville can be.

  • http://freevideolectures.com AnkammaRao

    Yes, Salman is one guy started providing the online education free along with MIT, stanford, Harvard and NPTEL. His vision to make the learning free is very appreciable. 

    Thanks
    Ak
    http://freevideolectures.com

  • AionNV

    Sad.

  • AionNV

    Sad.

  • AionNV

    Sad.

  • AionNV

    Well, to be fair, he’s in Machias.

  • Anonymous

    I wish I would have had something like this 50+ years ago.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DJHNJADSITO5PW2V6YT7I5IEPU W

    Great idea.  Public education has run its course. We need more schools, competition, innovation, and value. It’s time to privatize education. Public schools rarely improve, because they do not respond to market forces.  Low cost, budget schools will fill the void left by public schools.  Only then will real change and innovation like this be possible.

  • Anonymous

    As a homeschool mom, I am always looking for ways to improve my teaching methods.  Children learn best, at least mine does, by providing a variety of methods for the subject being taught: verbal instruction, hands-on learning, writing, using the five senses as much as possible, reading and research.  There isn’t just one tried and true method that fits for each and every student.  That thought is what is wrong with our educational system today.  If you can incorporate a variety of methods to teach a concept, that concept is constantly being reinforced by targeting both hemispheres of the brain without the mindless droning of repetition.

  • Anonymous

    As a homeschool mom, I am always looking for ways to improve my teaching methods.  Children learn best, at least mine does, by providing a variety of methods for the subject being taught: verbal instruction, hands-on learning, writing, using the five senses as much as possible, reading and research.  There isn’t just one tried and true method that fits for each and every student.  That thought is what is wrong with our educational system today.  If you can incorporate a variety of methods to teach a concept, that concept is constantly being reinforced by targeting both hemispheres of the brain without the mindless droning of repetition.

  • Anonymous

    As a homeschool mom, I am always looking for ways to improve my teaching methods.  Children learn best, at least mine does, by providing a variety of methods for the subject being taught: verbal instruction, hands-on learning, writing, using the five senses as much as possible, reading and research.  There isn’t just one tried and true method that fits for each and every student.  That thought is what is wrong with our educational system today.  If you can incorporate a variety of methods to teach a concept, that concept is constantly being reinforced by targeting both hemispheres of the brain without the mindless droning of repetition.

  • Anonymous

    As a homeschool mom, I am always looking for ways to improve my teaching methods.  Children learn best, at least mine does, by providing a variety of methods for the subject being taught: verbal instruction, hands-on learning, writing, using the five senses as much as possible, reading and research.  There isn’t just one tried and true method that fits for each and every student.  That thought is what is wrong with our educational system today.  If you can incorporate a variety of methods to teach a concept, that concept is constantly being reinforced by targeting both hemispheres of the brain without the mindless droning of repetition.

  • Anonymous

    As a homeschool mom, I am always looking for ways to improve my teaching methods.  Children learn best, at least mine does, by providing a variety of methods for the subject being taught: verbal instruction, hands-on learning, writing, using the five senses as much as possible, reading and research.  There isn’t just one tried and true method that fits for each and every student.  That thought is what is wrong with our educational system today.  If you can incorporate a variety of methods to teach a concept, that concept is constantly being reinforced by targeting both hemispheres of the brain without the mindless droning of repetition.

  • Anonymous

     Love it! Got the kids on there now to be ready for next year and brushing up on a bit of Differential Equations myself: it’s been a while!

    I’m really glad to see teachers open to the idea: looks like a great tool. I know I’ll be telling my local principal about it!

  • Anonymous

     Love it! Got the kids on there now to be ready for next year and brushing up on a bit of Differential Equations myself: it’s been a while!

    I’m really glad to see teachers open to the idea: looks like a great tool. I know I’ll be telling my local principal about it!

  • Anonymous

     Love it! Got the kids on there now to be ready for next year and brushing up on a bit of Differential Equations myself: it’s been a while!

    I’m really glad to see teachers open to the idea: looks like a great tool. I know I’ll be telling my local principal about it!

  • http://www.facebook.com/antonio.giarratano Antonio Giarratano

    I have gone to two Univesities, yes, that’s right, I will have two Bachelors Degrees. My first from NYU and my second will be from UMaine. You say we have the highest number of college graduates in history. Have you actaully listened to these graduates. most are dumber then a door post. I feel ashamed sometimes when I go to class. The high-schoolers that come in from the Early Start Program are more intelligent then most. Universes have lowered their standards, started offering more “online” learning, what a joke.

    I love technology. I have a laptop, a PC, a PDA, and a Smartphone. I still use pencil and paper to do math, when appropriate, I read every night, (on a kindle), so I am not knocking the internet or what this stands for, all I am saying is that Parents have the responsibility to help educate their children, not Khan, not the internet. It is a tool, not a method.

    It’s amazing, we have had classrooms, parents, and teachers for how many centuries? Now, all of a sudden, what has worked for centuries is “obsolete” and something new and improved is brought in and molded to pander to the lazy.
    Try motivating your kids to pay attention in school and help them with their homework more often. Get then out of the house and acting like kids should be, like they have fore centuries.

  • Anonymous

    If you had any basic grasp of history you would know that the patterns in the past ‘haven’t’ worked. America has always lagged behind in education and the only times where we have pushed ahead it was with people educated in other countrys.

    Two Bachelors indeed, if our current education system is producing students as woefully inept at you then prehaps we need something as forward thinking as Khan Academy. Staying with an older educations system instead of growing and embracing the new will only cause us to fall farther behind.

    I would rather have my children learning from a dynamic, constantly evolving education resource then a text book printed 5 years ago.

    Falure to embrace new ideas is indicative of a stagnate society.

  • Anonymous

    Sad when someone can’t even read an article on a new development in edication without someone making some political Bull out of it.

  • Anonymous

    I homeschooled my children and each of them went to college with one of them serving three years in the Army. I agree with your observations about public schooled children. But I believe, as we found out, that when used properly all of this modern technology/media…you can learn anything about anything. The world is wide open when technology is used properly.

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Marketplace Coupons

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business