UM students, faculty voice concerns about likely cuts

Julia Hathaway of Veazie joined students at Wells Commons in protesting the Academic Program Prioritization Working Group's recommendations during Monday's information forum there on U Maine's Orono campus. Hathaway's daughter, Amber Hathaway, a sophomore Women's Studies majo, might have her major cut in accord with working group's recommendations. &quotWithout women's studies, we won't be able to take the steps necessary to achieve true gender equity, " said Julia Hathaway. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
Julia Hathaway of Veazie joined students at Wells Commons in protesting the Academic Program Prioritization Working Group's recommendations during Monday's information forum there on U Maine's Orono campus. Hathaway's daughter, Amber Hathaway, a sophomore Women's Studies majo, might have her major cut in accord with working group's recommendations. "Without women's studies, we won't be able to take the steps necessary to achieve true gender equity, " said Julia Hathaway. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
Posted March 29, 2010, at 9:14 p.m.
Members of the campus community form roundtable discussions as University of Maine President Robert Kennedy (foreground, right) talks with the media during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
Members of the campus community form roundtable discussions as University of Maine President Robert Kennedy (foreground, right) talks with the media during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
Nate Wildes of Cumberland, president of U Maine's Class of 2012, voices his questions and concerns to University of Maine Dean of the College Liberal Arts and Sciences Dean Jeffrey Hecker (not pictured) as Hecker addressed the campus community during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations at Wells Commons on U Maine's Orono campus. Next to Wildes was Abby James (on left) of Owls Head and Margaret Libby (right) of Mt. Vernon,ME. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
Nate Wildes of Cumberland, president of U Maine's Class of 2012, voices his questions and concerns to University of Maine Dean of the College Liberal Arts and Sciences Dean Jeffrey Hecker (not pictured) as Hecker addressed the campus community during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations at Wells Commons on U Maine's Orono campus. Next to Wildes was Abby James (on left) of Owls Head and Margaret Libby (right) of Mt. Vernon,ME. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
University of Maine President Robert Kennedy,left, talks with U Maine English professor Tony Brinkley during Monday's information forum on the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
University of Maine President Robert Kennedy,left, talks with U Maine English professor Tony Brinkley during Monday's information forum on the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
Many hands were raised and Jeffrey Hecker, Dean of the College Liberal Arts and Sciences, talked with concerned members of the campus community during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
Many hands were raised and Jeffrey Hecker, Dean of the College Liberal Arts and Sciences, talked with concerned members of the campus community during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
University of Maine President Robert Kennedy addresses members of the campus community during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. Behind President Kennedy (left to right) is Tyler Francke (cq) ( Maine Campus opinion editor and senior), Robert Dana (Vice President for Student Affairs and Dean of Students), Nyssa Gatcombe (cq) of Old Town (Vice President of Student Government) and Susan Hunter (APPWG chair and Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs and Provost). BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
University of Maine President Robert Kennedy addresses members of the campus community during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. Behind President Kennedy (left to right) is Tyler Francke (cq) ( Maine Campus opinion editor and senior), Robert Dana (Vice President for Student Affairs and Dean of Students), Nyssa Gatcombe (cq) of Old Town (Vice President of Student Government) and Susan Hunter (APPWG chair and Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs and Provost). BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
John Mahon (seated on floor), Dean of the College of Business, Public Policy and Health, addresses students concerns during an informal break-out discussion during Monday's information forum at the university's Wells Commons regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. Dean Mahon is a member of the working group. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
John Mahon (seated on floor), Dean of the College of Business, Public Policy and Health, addresses students concerns during an informal break-out discussion during Monday's information forum at the university's Wells Commons regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. Dean Mahon is a member of the working group. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
Jeremy Milton, center, of Old Town (U Maine Class of 2008 and now a grad student and teacher at Lee Academy) expresses his concerns to Susan Hunter, second from left,  (APPWG chair and Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs and Provost) during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. Next to them are U Maine music professor Anatole Wieck, left, and Drew Albert, right (a music education major) of Millinocket. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
Jeremy Milton, center, of Old Town (U Maine Class of 2008 and now a grad student and teacher at Lee Academy) expresses his concerns to Susan Hunter, second from left, (APPWG chair and Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs and Provost) during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Program Prioritization Group's recommendations. Next to them are U Maine music professor Anatole Wieck, left, and Drew Albert, right (a music education major) of Millinocket. BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
University of Maine food science and nutrition major Rafael Garcia, left,  of New Fairfield, CT voices his concerns about the proposed program cuts to U Maine President Robert Kennedy during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Prograpm Prioritization Group's recommendations at Wells Commons on U Maine's Orono campus. Next to Garcia were sophomore Leland Arris (second from left) of Freeport, ME (an international affairs major with a concentration in Spanish) and freshman Zach Hall of Lebanon, ME ( an international affairs major with a concetration in German and another major in French). BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
BDN
University of Maine food science and nutrition major Rafael Garcia, left, of New Fairfield, CT voices his concerns about the proposed program cuts to U Maine President Robert Kennedy during Monday's information forum regarding the Academic Prograpm Prioritization Group's recommendations at Wells Commons on U Maine's Orono campus. Next to Garcia were sophomore Leland Arris (second from left) of Freeport, ME (an international affairs major with a concentration in Spanish) and freshman Zach Hall of Lebanon, ME ( an international affairs major with a concetration in German and another major in French). BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS

ORONO, Maine — More than 200 concerned University of Maine students and faculty members questioned the school’s academic administrators during a public forum Monday about an academic prioritization report released last week that calls for $12.3 million in budget cuts. The proposed cuts would eliminate majors in women’s studies, foreign languages, public administration, performing arts and other areas of study.

The report generated by the Academic Program Prioritization Working Group proposed changes that would result in 80 fewer faculty positions by 2014 along with a reduction in undergraduate academic majors from 86 to 70 and a reduction in master’s degrees from 64 to 58.

The total planned reductions amount to 15.4 percent of this year’s total budgets for all five of UMaine’s colleges that will be affected by the changes. UMaine Provost Susan Hunter, who chaired the working group, said last week that the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences took the biggest cuts at around $4 million.

Monday’s public session in Wells Conference Center was held in a format of free-form round-table discussions during which the deans of the five UMaine colleges answered questions, addressed concerns and took comments.

Today’s Poll

Do you think the University of Maine will have trouble attracting quality students if it cuts some academic programs?

Yes

No

Some who attended Monday’s sessions said the deans and others seemed straightforward in their answers, but didn’t assuage their concerns.

Emily Lanzikos, who is studying music education — a major not slated for elimination — questioned cutting the music performance major.

“I got [my questions] somewhat answered, but I didn’t like the answers, of course,” said Lanzikos, a first-year student from Pittsfield.

“How are they going to save money by cutting classes which make money? It made no sense to me,” she added. “In a sad way, I understand getting rid of the B.A. in music, but performance is such a big part of music. You don’t just go to music to read out of a book. You go to perform. And I don’t understand why they’re get-ting rid of a huge major, because they think some faculty might retire.”

Some of the cost savings will be realized, according to the working group report, if positions aren’t filled as faculty retire.

The concern of the report’s authors is that if those positions aren’t filled due to budget constraints, a department could weaken to the point a major could no longer be offered.

That was the justification Jeff Hecker, the dean of the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, gave for his recommendation to merge anthropology and sociology.

Hecker was peppered with dozens of questions about the future of other areas of study such as French, German, Spanish, Latin, theater and music, all of which could disappear as majors even though lower-level classes and some upper-level classes would still be offered.

“By merging with anthropology, we’d have one person who’s being pulled away from teaching to take on administrative responsibilities as opposed to two people,” Hecker said. “I would prefer to be investing in sociology, but looking forward it’s hard for me to see where the money would come from to invest in sociology, so I’m trying my best to see what resources would be left and how best to use those resources.”

If approved, the working group’s recommendations would be phased in between July 1, 2011, and June 30, 2014. Students now enrolled would be able to complete their programs.

The next phase in the academic prioritization plan will come April 8, when Hunter is expected to submit her recommendations to the president.

The president’s final report will be out at the end of April, Hunter added.

Several students and members of the public protested the proposed cuts in the conference center lobby with chants and signs.

Kennedy, Hunter and others answered questions as they wandered the conference center listening to the discussions.

The line to speak with Kennedy was 15-people deep at one point.

Students Scott LaFlamme, Evan Boutilier and Ben Breadmore questioned the president about a proposal to eliminate the department of public administration, which is the only academic department slated for complete elimination.

All three said they had wanted to stay in Maine to pursue master’s degrees in public administration.

“If there’s no program to come back to, we’re going out of state,” said Boutilier, a senior from Oakfield. “If we go out of state, we might not come back.”

Second-year political science major Nate Wildes of Cumberland said he’s concerned the working group report was too focused on cuts and not enough on growth.

“When a business enters a crisis, they fix the crisis by cutting employees and cutting costs,” Wildes said, “and reassuring stockholders with an action plan for the future that lays out how they’re going to recoup those losses. We’ve seen no action plan.”

At least one working group member wasn’t pleased with the outcomes of the report.

Michael Grillo, an art and art history professor who is vice president of the faculty senate, said cuts to majors in, for example, foreign languages, have universitywide effects.

“What we have to be looking at is some kind of system of [doing] greater interdisciplinarity without losing the disciplines,” said Grillo, who first saw about 1½ weeks ago the report’s specific recommendations. “The deans are beginning to explore this. I think the [UMaine System] has not, and it needs to. Any department that thinks it can operate as a silo and maintain the status quo is deluding itself.”

Several departments slated for cuts have approached Hunter and others about presenting their own restructuring programs.

“I think people basically understand that there is a fiscal reality that is driving all of this,” Hunter said about two hours into the session. “What we’re hoping is that people will take this opportunity to think creatively about economies that we can be achieving.”

For more information about the Academic Program Prioritization Working Group report, go to www.umaine.edu/achievingsustainability/

SEE COMMENTS →

ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business
ADVERTISEMENT | Grow your business

Similar Articles

More in State